PPA 1840 — FORENSIC DEEP-DIVE CASE REPORT
Generated from: ./ppa_variant_hits.csv
Cases: 71 | Wide-context window: +/-100 lines

================================================================
CASE PPA-001 | 1838 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Walter Campbell | Mr. Robert Steuart | Mr. 
Mantell | Mr. Hawkins
Outcome:     Motion: carried on
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: That the Report | Books and Papers | That the said Papers
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S3V0042P0 | S3V0044P0 | S3V0045P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_093

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):
read ; and ordered to lie upon the Table. 


Petitions from Leeds ;—Hampstead ;—and, Sal- Idolatry 
ford; praying the House to prohibit the interference (I&gt;die- ) 


of British functionaries inthe management of Ido- 
latrous Observances in India,—were presented, and 
read ; and ordered to lie upon the Table. 

A Petition 








Pilota 


Brick: 


Eccle 
Com! 


Post 


Edu 
(Ire 


Fic 
(Se 









































2 VicToriZ. 


Pilotage Bil, A Petition of James and George Burns, and others, 
residing in Glasgow, praying that the Pilotage Bill 
may pass into a law, was presented, and read; and 


ordered to lie upon the Table. 


A Petition of Master Brick-makers and Brick- 
builders in Glasgow, praying for the repeal of the 
duty on Bricks, was presented, and read ; and or- 
dered to lie upon the Table. 


A Petition of the Archdeacon and Clergy of the 
Archdeaconry of Coventry, praying the House to 
stay the Proceedings of the Ecclesiastical Commis- 
sioners, and not to sanction any further alterations 
in the constitution, discipline or services of the 
Church, till an opportunity shall have been afforded 
through her legitimate organs, of deliberating and 
expressing her mind respecting the meditated 
changes, was presented, and read; and ordered to 
lie upon the Table. 


Bricks. 


Ecclesiastical 
Commission. 


Postage. Petitions from Gosport ;—Crail ;—and, Charter- 


house Hinton; praying for the establishment of a 
low and uniform rate of Pos

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Tithe | Municipal | Railway | 2 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Stockdale v Hansard case; Stay of proceedings referenced; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-002 | 1838 | s.3 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Earl of Winchilsea | Sir Henry Hoskins | Earl of Ripon | Viscount Melbourne | Lord Ellenborough | Duke of Wellington | Earl of Wicklow | Mr. Nicholls
Outcome:     Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: Motion withdrawn
Defendant:   have his
Publication: The Morning Chronicle | On the Motion that the Report | The Report | The Times | To the Editor of The Times
Division:    Ayes 61, Noes 115
Hansard:     S3V0042P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

The Earl of Winchilsea gave notice, that after the recess he would bring forward a motion having for its object some improvements in the New Poor-law; giving, in the 436 first instance, a power to the board of guardians to regulate the dietary without the control of the Commissioners; and proposing, in the next, a declaratory clause respecting out-door relief. He would also propose a prohibitory clause; for, although he was a decided friend to labour in the workhouses, and would be the last person to offer opposition to anything in the way of labour, yet, as abuses had crept into some of the workhouses, more especially one in the county of Kent—namely, that belonging to the Bridge Union, he should feel it his duty to call their Lordships' attention to the subject, with a view to some fresh enactment respecting it. He had received a letter from a gentleman who bore the highest character for humanity, from which it appeared that in that Union relief was only afforded in connexion with punishment. It stated, that persons applying for lodging and provisions for one night, were compelled to carry a bag of sand 561bs. in weight for one hour, in order, as it were, to qualify themselves for the required relief; and, further, that if they remained in the workhouse during the next day, they were obliged to carry this bag of sand (of which he had a sample in his possession that had been sent to him) for two hours. Now, this he considered to be a perfect breach of the act. He drew the a

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: tithe | railway | Municipal | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-003 | 1839 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Thornley | Mr. Cresswell | Mr. Attwood | Lord Liverpool | Mr. Jeremiah Harman | Lord Castlereagh | Lord Ripon | Lord Melbourne
Outcome:     Motion: carried on | Motion: resolved that | Motion: House agreed | Motion: Motion agreed | Certificate issued/granted | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: passed by | Motion: resolved in
Defendant:   it was | in the | they might | in this | was the | thereby | had led | should appear
Publication: The Observer | He would also refer to the Report | He agreed with that Report | An article appeared in the Edinburgh Review | Edinburgh Review | I saw in the Morning Chronicle | Morning Chronicle | Polack had brought an action against the Times
Division:    Ayes 36, Noes 17 | Ayes 184, Noes 166 | Ayes 133, Noes 36 | Ayes 94, Noes 32 | Ayes 144, Noes 3 | Ayes 88, Noes 29 | Ayes 36, Noes 14 | Ayes 32, Noes 14
Hansard:     S3V0047P0 | S3V0048P0 | S3V0049P0 | S3V0050P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_094

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Mr. F. T. Baring said, that the sheriffs were answerable for the javelin-men, and therefore ought to have the appointment,

The House again divided on the question that the clause remain:—Ayes 36 Noes 17:—Majority 19.

Bill passed.

Lord John Russell moved for leave to bring in two Bills, one to continue the Poor-law Commission for one year, the other to amend the law relative to the assessment and collection of rates to the Poor-law Amendment Act. He had already stated, that it was too late in the present Session to introduce the bill he had originally intended as to details, which had been under discussion both in the House and before a Select Committee; but all he now proposed to do was, to make a provision to prevent any occurrence to put an end suddenly to the Poor-law Commissions. The bill would provide for the continuance of the commission for a year longer than it would now exist by law; it would now expire at the end of the next Session of Parliament. He wished, also, to introduce a bill to amend the system of the collection of rates. Much difficulty and inconvenience was now felt in the collection of the rates, in consequence of the different authorities between the board of guardians and the overseers. By this bill, he proposed to enable the board of guardians to order the collection of the county and other rates collected with the poor-rates.

Mr. Darby regretted that the noble Lord did not mean to introduce the bill as he originally intended; particularly he reg

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Corn law | corn law | election | Corn Law | Poor Law | Municipal | Election | Railway | 96 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Stockdale v Hansard case; Stay of proceedings referenced; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-004 | 1839 | s.3 | NEEDS_REVIEW
================================================================
Status:      NEEDS_REVIEW
MP/Lord:     Not extracted
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S3V0046P0
Journals:    nan

COMBINED CONTEXT: [No wide-context passage available — see existing knowledge report]

FORENSIC NOTES:
None
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-005 | 1840 | s.1 | NEEDS_REVIEW
================================================================
Status:      NEEDS_REVIEW
MP/Lord:     Not extracted
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S3V0052P0
Journals:    nan

COMBINED CONTEXT: [No wide-context passage available — see existing knowledge report]

FORENSIC NOTES:
Speaker's certificate referenced
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-006 | 1840 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Earl of

African Trade | Lord

Administration | Mr. Hume | Lord Hotham | Duke of

Church | Lord

Austria | Lord

Children | Mr. Pare
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: That the Report | The Morning Chronicle | Church Leases Report | Stamped and Unstamped Papers | Printed Papers | London

Unstamped Papers see Stamped Papers
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S3V0051P0 | S3V0052P0 | S3V0054P0 | S3V0055P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_095

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

40. An Act for naturalizing August Wilhelm Bernhard Promoli .

41. An Act to dissolve the Marriage of James Perry Esquire with Elizabeth Margaret his Wife, and to enable him to marry again; and for other Purposes.

42. An Act to dissolve the Marriage of George Lloyd Esquire with Athalie Pulcherie Clotilde his now Wife, and to enable him to marry again; and for other Purposes therein mentioned.

43. An Act for naturalizing Frederick Shultze .

44. An Act for naturalizing Arnold Julius Wolff .

45. An Act for naturalizing Gregorio José Martinez del Rio .

46. An Act for naturalizing His Excellency Don Lorenzo Duke Sforza Cesarini .

47. An Act for naturalizing Alexander Liebert .

48. An Act to dissolve the Marriage of Ann Battersby with Arthur Battersby her now Husband, and to enable her to marry again; and for other Purposes therein mentioned.

49. An Act to dissolve the Marriage of Joseph Groome Deane with Rachel his now Wife, and to enable him to marry again; and for other Purposes therein mentioned.

50. An Act to dissolve the Marriage of Jonathan Warr with Betty his now wife, and to enable him to marry again; and for other Purposes therein mentioned.

51. An Act to dissolve the Marriage of Alexander Grant Esquire with Maria Theresa his now Wife, and to enable him to marry again; and for other Purposes.

52. An Act to dissolve the Marriage of James Close with Louisa his now Wife, and to enable him to marry again; and for other Purposes.

53. An Act to dissolve the Marriag

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Municipal | Election | Railway | Corn Law | Poor Law | Tithe | 89 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Stockdale v Hansard case; Stay of proceedings referenced; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-007 | 1840 | s.3 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Sir Ralph Howard | Duke of Somerset | Lord Seaford | Earl of Auckland | Duke of Wellington | Viscount Melbourne | Earl of Winchilsea | Viscount The
Outcome:     Motion: carried on | Motion: passed by | Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: passed on | Motion: carried by | Motion: passed without | Motion: resolved that | Motion: House agreed
Defendant:   served the | issued | be called | brought his | was convicted | in the | but the | brought an
Publication: London Gazette | Parliament with regard to Post | Ministers have done with respect to the Post | From a corrected Report | The London and Westminster Review | The man at the Post | I put a letter into the Post | The Times
Division:    Ayes 286, Noes 167 | Ayes 206, Noes 117 | Ayes 209, Noes 25 | Ayes 249, Noes 100 | Ayes 239, Noes 135 | Ayes 116, Noes 36 | Ayes 64, Noes 166 | Ayes 205, Noes 90
Hansard:     S3V0051P0 | S3V0052P0 | S3V0054P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_095

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Mr. Law contended, that the argument of the learned Attorney-General against ordering the sheriffs to produce their writs held equally good against ordering the inferior officer to produce his warrant. He hoped that the House would be consistent in their course on this occasion, and that if they required the inferior officer to produce his warrant, they would at the same time be prepared to face the real grounds of the conduct of the sheriffs in the performance of their public duty. He trusted that they did not already begin to flinch from the consequences of their pro- 101 ceedings. A short time ago they were afraid of the judges, and now they seemed to be afraid of the writs in the possession of the sheriffs. He trusted the noble Lord would either abandon so much of his motion as related to the production of the warrant by the inferior officer, or that he would consent to an amendment, ordering the sheriffs to produce that legal authority which they were bound to obey.

Mr. Kelly moved an amendment to the effect before stated by him.

Lord J. Russell agreed with his hon. and learned Friend in thinking that the amendment was unnecessary, as the sheriffs would bring the writs as their justification; but he would not object to such an amendment.

The House divided:—Ayes 206; Noes 117: Majority 89.

Motion, as amended, agreed to.

The Speaker stated, that the House had been to the House of Peers, where her Majesty had been pleased to deliver a Speech from her Throne, a copy of

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Municipal | municipal | trespass | election | returning officer | turnpike | railway | Duchy | 441 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-008 | 1841 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Colquhoun | Lord Stanley | Mr. Ashton Yates | Lord Morpeth | Mr. Trotter | Mr. Hodges | Mr. Fielden | Mr. Bailey
Outcome:     Motion: bill passed | Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill read | Motion: passed without | Motion: passed by | Motion: Motion withdrawn | Motion: bill agreed | Motion: bill read
Defendant:   jurisdiction of
Publication: Church of England Quarterly Review | Church of England Quarterly Magazine | Quarterly Review | Morning Post | The Government Gazette | Corfu had been opened by the Post | Mint and to the Post | That the Paper
Division:    Ayes 37, Noes 86 | Ayes 36, Noes 58 | Ayes 10, Noes 28 | Ayes 40, Noes 39 | Ayes 150, Noes 36
Hansard:     S3V0056P0 | S3V0057P0 | S3V0059P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_096

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Petitions presented. By Mr. Colquhoun, and Sir R. Inglis, from places in Suffolk, Shropshire, Norfolk, and Scotland, against the Continuance of the Grant to Maynooth.—By Sir C. Styles, and Sergeant Jackson, from Donegal, and Kilkenny, in favour of Lord Stanley's Irish Registration Bill.—By Mr. Ashton Yates, Mr. M. J. O'Connell, and Mr. E. Roche, from Carlow, Kerry, and Cork, for Lord Morpeth's Irish Registration Bill,—By Mr. Trotter, Mr. T. Parker, Mr. Hodges, Mr. Fielden, and others, from West Surry, places in Lancashire, Canterbury, and other places, against the Continuance of the Poor-law Bill.—By Mr. Bailey, and Mr. Plumptre, from Gloucester, and East Kent, for Church Extension.—By Mr. Aglionby, from Cumberland, that the recommendation of the Marine Society Committee may be carried into effect.—By Sir R. Bateson, and Mr. Fox Maule, from Presbyteries in Ireland, from Lawrence-Kirk, and other places, against Church Patronage in Scotland.—By Mr. Grimsditch, Mr. M. Phillips, and Mr. Turner, from Manchester, against the Copyright of Designs Bill.—By Mr. T. Duncombe, from the Chartist Association of Liverpool, for Pardon to Frost, Williams, and Jones, the Release of Mr. O'Connor, and Mr. Bronterre O'Brien, fot the Dismissal of Ministers, and for Universal Suffrage.—By Lord Eliot, from Cornwall, for Medical Reform.

Mr. Wallace in rising to bring before the House the motion of which he had given notice, said he would endeavour to be as brief as he could, and he trusted he shoul

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: election | trespass | returning officer | municipal | Poor Law | Turnpike | Railway | Election | 8 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Stockdale v Hansard case; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-009 | 1842 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Spence | Mr. Blake | Mr. Kemble Pulpit | Mr. Melvill | Duke of Wellington | Mr. Kemble | Mr. Melvin | Mr. Hawes
Outcome:     Motion: passed without | Motion: passed by | Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: House agreed
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    Ayes 118, Noes 24
Hansard:     S3V0065P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

(Signed) " A. R. BLAKE."

He need only add that it will be in the recollection of the House, that the time of his making use of the word " convicted " was not in his speech on the 30th of June, but at the time of his putting a question to the noble Lord the Secretary for Ireland, to know if it was the intention of the Government to prosecute Mr. Spence in con. sequence of what had taken place before Mr. Blake. The noble Lord understood his meaning, and answered his question to his satisfaction. He admitted that the word "convicted " might imply more than he intended should be understood; but it was made use of only in the question to the noble Lord, and not in his speech on the 30th of June. Therefore he could not admit that the learned Recorder of Dublin was in any way justified in making the statements he did, or deny that a forgery had been committed, when there was not 640 a shadow of a doubt that such had been the case.

On the first Order of the Day being moved,

Mr. Kemble Pulpit . Now it was not fair that a clergyman should be made responsible for certain expressions reported to have been used by him, and published without his sanction. At the same time there was no man more capable of defending himself, or less likely to shrink from the responsibility of any expression he might have uttered, than that rev. gentleman. The allusion to the Corn-laws which had been quoted was merely used by Mr. Melvill incidentally in the course of his sermon, and addressed to his heare

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: tithe | Election | election | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-010 | 1842 | s.3 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Brougham | Earl of Stanhope | Duke of Buckingham | Duke of Rutland | Earl of Zetland | Earl of Ripon | Lord Melbourne | Lord Ashburton
Outcome:     Motion: carried on | Motion: carried without | Motion: bill passed | Motion: passed on | Motion: Bill read | Motion: passed by
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: That the said Papers | That the said Paper
Division:    Ayes 285, Noes 188
Hansard:     S3V0062P0 | S3V0063P0 | S3V0064P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_097

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

4. Resolved, That from and after a day to be named, goods the produce or manufacture of the Islands of Guernsey, Jersey, Alderney or Sark, when imported from such Islands into the British Possessions in America or the Mauritius, shall be admitted to entry upon payment of the said Duties as are payable upon the like goods the produce or manufacture of the United Kingdom, or of any of the said Pos-sessions.

5. Resolved, That the Chairman be instructed to move for leave to bring in a Bill to amend the Laws relating to the Trade of the British Possessions Abroad.

House resumed. Resolution agreed to. Resolutions to be reported.

House adjourned.

MINUTES.] BILLS. Public — 1 a Mutiny; Marine Mutiny. 2 a Corn Importation; Lunacy.

Reported. —Indemnity; Public Works.

Private. —2 a Fieville's Naturalization; Benecke's Naturalization; Wakeyhill Inclosure.

Reported. —(specially) Cottenham Inclosure; Brandling Junction Railway.

3 a and passed:—Bradford (York) Waterworks. PETITIONS PRESENTED. By Earl Fitzwilliam, and Lord Brougham, from Gisbro, Huddersfield, Leicester, Leeds, Arbroath, and St. Mary's, Newington, against the Income-tax.—By the Earl of Stanhope, and the Duke of Buckingham, from Farmers in Chapham, Gillingham, Kent, Banff, Forfar, Surrey, and a great many other places, against any Alteration of the Corn-laws.—By Earl Fitzwilliam, the Duke of Rutland, and the Earl of Zetland, from Kirkburton, and various places, in favour of Free Trade.—By Earl Fitzwilliam, from the Sho

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | trespass | election | Corn Law | Poor Law | 3 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Stockdale v Hansard case; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-011 | 1843 | s.2 | NEEDS_REVIEW
================================================================
Status:      NEEDS_REVIEW
MP/Lord:     Not extracted
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S3V0067P0, S3V0070P0
Journals:    nan

COMBINED CONTEXT: [No wide-context passage available — see existing knowledge report]

FORENSIC NOTES:
None
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-012 | 1843 | s.3 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Cottenham | Lord Brougham | Mr. Rothery | Mr. Brandinell | Earl of Aberdeen | Earl of Clarendon | Earl of Haddington | Lord Monteagle
Outcome:     Motion: carried on | Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: Bill read | Motion: passed by | Motion: resolved that | Stay of proceedings | Motion: agreed on | Motion: bill passed
Defendant:   into custody | or his | till it | with | had sued | was the | therefore sued | denying the
Publication: From a corrected Report | The London City Mission Report | Manchester Sunday School Magazine | Printed Papers | Morning Chronicle | In the Dublin Evening Post | Roscommon Journal | Lord Lynedoch requests the editor of the Morning Chronicle His noble Friend then published what had been said by him in
Division:    Ayes 94, Noes 80 | Ayes 133, Noes 232 | Ayes 129, Noes 35 | Ayes 135, Noes 71 | Ayes 66, Noes 143 | Ayes 15, Noes 39 | Ayes 100, Noes 54 | Ayes 97, Noes 46
Hansard:     S3V0067P0 | S3V0068P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Mr. H. Fitzroy said, that John Brown never was connected with the Agricultural Society as secretary, or in any other capacity; he never attended any meetings of that society, and the society would utterly repudiate any such sentiments as those ascribed to him.

Mr. Darby amidst cries of "Divide!" begged to confirm what the hon. Member for Lewes had said, expressed himself to the same effect.

Mr. Ward was of opinion that the hon. Member fcr Warrington thought of nothing but protection The right hon. Baronet said a committee was not necessary, and that the object could be accomplished by official returns; he differed from the right hon. Baronet, and preferred a committee. He wanted to obtain such information as would hasten the conviction of the right hon. Baronet that the laws must be altered, so that he might fulfil his pledge that no false consistency should prevent him from acting upon that conviction.

Mr. Bankes's amendment was negatived without a division.

The House divided on the original ques- 963 tion:—Ayes 133;Noes 232:—Majority 99.

Mr. T. Duncombe moved for leave to bring in a bill to repeal so much of the 10th George 2nd, c. 28, as relates to common players of interludes, and to make other provisions in lieu thereof. He had framed his bill partly on account of the severity 966 with which the statute of George 2nd had been lately enforced at Liverpool. The same thing had been done here twenty-two years ago, when the proprietors of the patent theatres summoned th

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | railway | turnpike | tithe | trespass | election | Election | Municipal | 13 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-013 | 1844 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Williams | Mr. Craven Berkeley | Mr. Pakington | Mr. Christie | Mr. Bond | Baron Rolfe | Lord Denman | Mr. Wortley
Outcome:     Motion: Bill read | Motion: House agreed | Motion: carried on
Defendant:   Mr | had gone
Publication: Members who had Bills on the Paper
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S3V0072P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_099

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Mr. Williams , but it also proposed to increase the travelling allowance; and, therefore he should divide the House against it.

Mr. Craven Berkeley would suggest that as the only clause referring to an increase of allowances was the 20th, which he proposed to move the omission of, it would be undesirable to divide the House against the whole Bill.

Lord J. Russell hoped, that to meet the convenience of the House, with reference to the important debate now in progress, the hon. Gentleman as well as other hon. Members who had Bills on the Paper, would consent to postpone them.

Mr. Pakington said, the noble Lord's object would be answered by reading the bill a second time pro forma, and taking 1313 the discussion on the details at a future stage.

Bill read a second time.

On the Question that the Speaker do now leave the Chair, for the House to go into a Committee on the Horse Racing Penalties Bill,

Mr. Christie rose to move as an amendment, "That it be an instruction to the Committee to extend the provisions of the Bill to all proceedings of common informers, under the authority of any penal statute." He said his object was to turn the Bill—which as it stood was a Bill to protect a few individuals, who, by violating a law, have incurred unreasonably high penalties, which were sued for by common informers, actuated, very probably, by malice, and a desire to put money into their pockets, but still the very motives on which the Legislature relied for the execution of the law 

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: trespass | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-014 | 1845 | s.3 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Viscount Ingestrie | Mr. Gladstone | Mr. Hayter | Mr. Muntz | Mr. Spooner | Mr. Wakley | Mr. Hogg | Mr. Liddell
Outcome:     Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: Bill introduced | Motion: Bill read | Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: resolved that | Motion: carried by | Motion: passed without
Defendant:   may take | may within | in recovering | in the | were not | to have | or any | and Mr
Publication: Notice upon the Paper | Secret Committee upon the Post | Saturday last I was summoned before the Post | Secret Committee on the Post | The Report | Among the Papers | Amongst the Papers | With respect to the Papers
Division:    Ayes 78, Noes 23 | Ayes 51, Noes 141 | Ayes 6, Noes 96 | Ayes 96, Noes 50
Hansard:     S3V0076P0 | S3V0077P0 | S3V0079P0 | S3V0080P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_100

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

3 o. and passed:—Copyholds Enfranchisement; District Courts and Prisons; Party Processions (Ireland); Western Australia; Farm Buildings; Loan Societies.

Private. — Reported. —Leeds Vicarage.

PETITIONS PRESENTED. By Mr. T. Duncombe, from Rigby Mason, Esq., for Amendment of Law of Controverted Elections.—By Viscount Ingestrie, from Staffordshire (8), and Mr. S. O'Brien, from Northampton (9), against Repeal of the Corn Laws.—By Mr. S. O'Brien, from Market Harborough, against Canal Companies Bill; and Mr. Gladstone, from Canal Companies (11), in favour of same.—By Mr. T. Duncombe, from A. Wivell, in favour of Damage by Fire Bill.—By Captain Pechell, from D. Macintyre, alleging Services.—By Mr. T. Duncombe, from Brandon, respecting Mildenhall Savings' Bank.—By Mr. B. Smith, from P. Pentin, for Redress.—By Mr. Hayter, from Exeter, against Railways Bill.—By Mr. T. Egerton, from Stockport, and Mr. T. Duncombe, from Dorchester, against Savings Banks Bill.

House in Committee on the Poor Law Amendment Bill.

On Clause 57, "Guardians under local Acts to conduct their proceedings in like manner as guardians appointed under the 4th and 5th Wm. IV., c. 76, and that parishes under local acts, with a population of more than 20,000, not to be united without the consent of the guardians."

Mr. T. Duncombe objected to the operation of this Clause being extended to those metropolitan parishes which were governed by local acts.

Sir J. Graham said, there were very few of the metropolitan paris

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Election | Corn Law | Railway | Stamp Duty | election | Poor Law | trespass | 11 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Stockdale v Hansard case; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-015 | 1846 | s.1 | NEEDS_REVIEW
================================================================
Status:      NEEDS_REVIEW
MP/Lord:     Not extracted
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S3V0082P0
Journals:    nan

COMBINED CONTEXT: [No wide-context passage available — see existing knowledge report]

FORENSIC NOTES:
Speaker's certificate referenced
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-016 | 1846 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Wynford | Lord Denman | Earl of Devon | Lord Brougham | Earl of Wicklow | Mr. Harlow | Mr. Baker | Sir Francis Burdett
Outcome:     Stay of proceedings | Motion: passed by | Motion: resolved in | Motion: Bill read | Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill introduced | Motion: passed without
Defendant:   before you | threaten to | in an | leave to | and his
Publication: The Report | House of Commons the Papers | House of Parliament has sold all the Papers | The Paper | Day for taking into consideration the Report | Order of the Day for receiving the Report | Wolverhampton Chronicle | Gentlemen who had Motions on the Paper
Division:    Ayes 11, Noes 68 | Ayes 11, Noes 34 | Ayes 40, Noes 34 | Ayes 30, Noes 18
Hansard:     S3V0081P0 | S3V0082P0 | S3V0085P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

House resumed. Committee to sit again.

House adjourned at a quarter past one.

MINUTES. Sat First. —The Lord Wynford, after the Death of his Father.

BILLS Public. —1 a. Colleges (Ireland); Waste Lands (Australia); Recognizances for Costs in Bills.

2 a. Administration of Justice (Court of Chancery) Acts Amendment; Constables, Public Works, (Ireland).

Reported. —Dog Stealing.

3 a. and passed:—Administration of Criminal Justice (Lord Denman).

Private. —1 a. Shuldham's Divorce; Lady's Island Lake and Tacumshin Lake Embankment; Monmouth and Hereford Railway; South Wales Railway; South Eastern Railway (Tunbridge to Tunbridge Wells).

2 a. Newport and Pontypool Railway; Aberdare Railway; London and South Western Metropolitan Extension Railway.

3 a. and passed;—Bristol and Exeter Railway Branches; Dublin and Belfast Junction Railway; Reversionary Interest Society; Middlesbro' and Redcar Railway; Waterford and Limerick Railway; Dublin and Drogheda Railway; Newry and Enniskillen Railway; North Union and Ribble Navigation Branch Railway; Saint Helen's Canal and Railway.

PETITIONS PRESENTED. From Guardians of Newcastle Union, for Alteration of Poor Law Act (Ireland) in respect to the Repayment of Money advanced for Building Workhouses.—By Marquess of Clanricarde, from Guardians of South Dublin Union, for Amendment of Poor Law Act (Ireland).—From Guardians of Galway Union, for Inquiry into Operation of Poor Law Act (Ireland), with a view to the Removal of certain evils complained

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | Poor Law | stamp duty | election | trespass | Municipal | Corn Law | 3 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Stockdale v Hansard case
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-017 | 1846 | s.3 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Ewart | Mr. Buller | Mr. Parker | Mr. Trelawny | Sir Francis Burdett | Mr. Williams | Mr. Mayer | Mr. Twyford
Outcome:     Motion: Motion withdrawn | Motion: Bill read | Motion: Resolved in | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: House agreed | Motion: passed by | Motion: carried on
Defendant:   should appear | should be | had recovered | could levy | would avail
Publication: Supply on the Paper | Returns made to that House by the Post | Wellington wished to know whether any Report | Brougham remarked that the Clerk of the Papers | General Pasley had made his Report | In framing their Report | House taking into its consideration the Report | Committee on Printed Papers
Division:    Ayes 78, Noes 46 | Ayes 82, Noes 48
Hansard:     S3V0081P0 | S3V0084P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Sir R. Peel said, it was not surprising, after four nights of fatiguing debate, that the state of the House should have been what it was. He had, however, redeemed the pledge he had given the hon. Gentleman, in reference to affording him an opportunity of bringing forward his Motion.

Mr. Ewart said, he should certainly bring it forward at a future period, though he would not do it to the interruption of the Supply Motions.

The Chancellor of the Exchequer said, that as the hon. Member who had brought forward the present Motion (Mr. Buller) had done so more for the purpose of bringing the subject of the tallow duty under the consideration of the Government, than in the expectation of being able to effect any immediate alteration of the duty, he should not follow him into the details of the question; though, had this Motion been pressed, he should have felt it to have been his duty to have resisted it, as well as the Motion of the hon. Member for Dumfries, had it been brought forward, on the ground that it would be impossible, after the great reductions in 1006 the duties on various articles which had been made already in the course of the present Session, to make any further reductions, even on an article which he acknowledged to be of so much importance as the one under discussion, without incurring the risk of great loss to the revenue of the country. He was not, therefore, disposed to go into the discussion of the question, or to prejudge its consideration at any future o

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: railway | Turnpike | Railway | Tithe | Poor Law | 8 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-018 | 1847 | s.3 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Goulburn | Mr. Smith | Mr. Roebuck | Mr. Hume | Duke of Devonshire | Mr. Bernal | Lord Chancellor Eldon | Lord Stanley
Outcome:     Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill agreed | Motion: House agreed
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    Ayes 155, Noes 61
Hansard:     S3V0087P0 | S3V0089P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_102

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):
Maperton, North Cheriton and Horsington;— Henry 
Albert Ingram and Owners, Lessees or Occupiers 
of lands upon the line of Railway thereinafter men- 
tioned ; —— Philip Abraham Barnes and John 
Barnes, and Owners, Lessees and Occupiers of 
lands upon the line of Railway thereinafter men- 
tioned ; Septimus Smith, and Owners, Lessees 
and Occupiers of land upon the line of Railway 
thereinafter mentioned ; Jonathan Kent, and 
Owners, Lessees and Occupiers of land upon the 
line of Railway thereinafter mentioned ; Right 
honourable Edward Berkeley Lord Portman ; 
Henry Field Fisher, of Blandford Forum, in the 
county of Dorset, Draper ; James John Farqu- 
harson, and Owners, Lessees and Occupiers of lands 
upon the line of Railway thereinafter mentioned ; 
William Naish Allford, of Sherborne, in the 
county of Dorset, Esquire, and Owners, Lessees 
and Occupiers of lands upon the line of Railway 
thereinafter mentioned ; Thomas Lyddon Sur- 
rage, of Clifton, in the county of Gloucester, Es- 
quire, and Owners, Lessees and Occupiers of land 
upon the line of Railway thereinafter mentioned ; 
William Manning Dodington, of Horsington, 
in the county of Somerset, Esquire ; and, the 
Right honourable Henry Hobhouse, of Hadspen 
House, in the parish of Pitcombe, in the county of 
Somerset; praying that they may be heard, by 
themselves, their counsel or agents, against certain 
parts of the Blandford and Bruton Railway Bill,— 
were presented, and read. 

And the said Petitions were or

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Poor Law | poor law | corn law | Railway | Turnpike | 2 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Stockdale v Hansard case; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-019 | 1848 | s.1 | NEEDS_REVIEW
================================================================
Status:      NEEDS_REVIEW
MP/Lord:     Not extracted
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S3V0095P0
Journals:    nan

COMBINED CONTEXT: [No wide-context passage available — see existing knowledge report]

FORENSIC NOTES:
None
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-020 | 1848 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Brougham | Mr. Chadwick | Mr. Nicholls | Mr. Nicholl | Mr. Chad | Mr. Fox Maule | Mr. Hume | Sir Howard Douglas
Outcome:     Motion: Bill read | Motion: Resolved in | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: carried on | Motion: passed without | Motion: resolved in | Motion: carried by | Motion: agreed on
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Order of the Day for receiving the Report | Weekly Chronicle | Motion Paper | The Times | It must be true if the Times | The Examiner | Order in Council in the Gazette | Having recently seen in the Times
Division:    Ayes 138, Noes 20 | Ayes 128, Noes 25 | Ayes 168, Noes 135 | Ayes 296, Noes 19 | Ayes 134, Noes 125 | Ayes 253, Noes 186
Hansard:     S3V0092P0 | S3V0093P0 | S3V0094P0 | S3V0095P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_103

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

PETITIONS PRESENTED. From Glasgow, for the passing of a General Harbour Conservancy Bill for all Ports, Harbours, &c. in the United Kingdom.—By Lord Brougham, from Stranraer, against the Mussel Fisheries (Scotland) Bill.—From Stockton-on-Tees, and Kingston-on-Hull, for the Enactment of Sanitary Measures —By Earl Grey, from Free Inhabitants of the District of Dingog, that Transportation may not be removed from New South 324 Wales on any Terms and Conditions whatever; and from Inhabitants of Port Philip, for the Prevention of the Indiscriminate Pledging of the Land Funds as a Security for a Joint Debt, and that the District of Port Philip may be Separated from the Government of the Colony of New South Wales.

The MARQUESS of LANSDOWNE moved the Third Reading of the Poor Laws Administration Bill.

LORD BROUGHAM had serious objections to this Bill, and in order to record those objections he should take the sense of the House upon its third reading. He objected to the manner in which it was proposed to pay the chief officer, the President of the Poor Law Administration, who was to be entitled to hold a seat in the Commons' House of Parliament. After the Bill had passed the Commons, and had gone through a second reading in their Lordships' House, the salary had been fixed at 2,000 l . per annum; but power was given in the same clause to the Lords Commissioners of the Treasury to alter that amount from time to time. Now this was not a decorous manner of providing for a public funct

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Poor Law | Railway | railway | turnpike | trespass | municipal | Tithe | election | 7 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Stockdale v Hansard case; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-021 | 1848 | s.3 | NEEDS_REVIEW
================================================================
Status:      NEEDS_REVIEW
MP/Lord:     Not extracted
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S3V0093P0
Journals:    nan

COMBINED CONTEXT: [No wide-context passage available — see existing knowledge report]

FORENSIC NOTES:
None
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-022 | 1849 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Ashley | Mr. Gladstone | Mr. Urquhart | Mr. Graham | Mr. Gardner | Mr. Goring | Baron Rothschild | Lord Eldon
Outcome:     Motion: Bill read | Motion: carried on | Motion: Motion withdrawn | Motion: passed by
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: From a published Report | Jamaica Times | January last the Gazette | Extract from the Times | Dublin Gazette | That the Report
Division:    Ayes 99, Noes 196 | Ayes 109, Noes 203 | Ayes 118, Noes 74 | Ayes 180, Noes 124 | Ayes 34, Noes 142
Hansard:     S3V0096P0 | S3V0097P0 | S3V0098P0 | S3V0100P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_104

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Ordered, That the Account of the Rates by which | 
the Official Valuation of the principal Articles im- | 
ported into England, Scotland, and Ireland sepa- 
rately is estimated; also, a Return of the Rates at | 
which Foreign and Colonial Products are valued, | 
when exported from England, Scotland and Ireland, 
separately and respectively ; together with an Ac- | 
count of the Rates fixed for the Official Valuation | 
of the principal Articles of British and Irish Pro- | 


duce and Manufactures exported from England, | 


Scotland and Ireland separately and respectively, 
which was presented upon the 18th day of May 
1826, be re-printed. 


Resolved, That an humble Address be presented 
to Her Majesty, that She will be graciously pleased 
to give directions that there be laid before this 
House, Copies or Extracts of any Despatches rela- 
tive to Emigration to the North American and 
Australian Colonies, since those moved for on the 
15th day of May last. 

Ordered, That the said Address be presented to 
Her Majesty by such Members of this House as are 
of Her Majesty’s Most honourable Privy Council. 


Resolved, That an humble Address be presented 
to Her Majesty, that She will be graciously pleased 
to give directions, that there be laid before this 
House, Copies or Extracts of any Despatches re- 
lative to the Affairs of New Zealand (in continua- 
tion of the Papers presented in August 1848.) 

Ordered, That. the said Address be presented to 
Her Majesty by such Member

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: municipal | election | Poor Law | Turnpike | Railway | 3 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-023 | 1849 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Stanley | Lord Grey | Lord Castlereagh | Lord Lansdowne | Mr. Grey | Mr. Fox | Mr. Abercrombie | Lord Dunfermline
Outcome:     Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: Bill read | Motion: Motion withdrawn | Motion: Bill agreed | Motion: passed by | Stay of proceedings | Motion: Motion negatived
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Member for Glasgow had a Motion on the Paper | Government business stood on the Paper | Ministers and the Times | His authority for that statement was the Report | From a corrected Report | Motion for Papers | Notice Paper | Penny Post
Division:    Ayes 76, Noes 21 | Ayes 141, Noes 22 | Ayes 16, Noes 107 | Ayes 62, Noes 28 | Ayes 26, Noes 63 | Ayes 60, Noes 25 | Ayes 85, Noes 19 | Ayes 103, Noes 90
Hansard:     S3V0098P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

The CHANCELLOR OF THE EXCHEQUER said, that after what had passed, he would limit the vote to 170,000 l .

MR. HUME said, that the concession which the Chancellor of the Exchequer had been compelled to make did not satisfy him. He protested against the Imperial Treasury being called upon to become responsible for the debts of the colonies. It must be very difficult for any person who had attended to the debate to know what the facts of the case really were. One right hon. Gentleman after another rose and repudiated the responsibility of having sanctioned the loan, and yet the country was called upon to pay the money. As far as he could make out the facts of the case, they were these:—In 1844 Lord Stanley authorised the chartering of certain ships to convey Coolies to the West Indies, the expenses attending which was to be defrayed by bills drawn upon the colonies; those bills had not been paid by the colonies; and now this country was called upon to pay them. It was necessary that the House should have Lord Stanley's orders before it, in order that it might know to what extent this country was liable. For aught that had been stated, the importation of Coolies might still be going on. [Mr. HAWES: It has been stopped.] Well, it was not the less necessary that the House should be in possession of the whole of the correspondence. It appeared from a paper which he held in his hand, that, on the 16th of February, Lord Grey wrote to the Governors of Guiana and Trinidad that the Gove

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: trespass | election | municipal | Poor Law | Railway | railway | Municipal | 4 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-024 | 1849 | s.3 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Abinger | Sir James Scarlett | Mr. Labouchere | Earl of Lincoln | Mr. Gladstone | Lord Grey | Mr. Meurant | Lord Normanby
Outcome:     Motion: Motion negatived | Motion: House agreed | Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: Motion agreed
Defendant:   writes to
Publication: Chirurgical Review | House of Commons upon the Post | Lord referred triumphantly to the Post | At present the gross revenue of the Post
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S3V0096P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

MR. SERJEANT TALFOURD said, that the whole matter had been fully considered 328 seventeen years ago, and at that period the time for commencing Hilary Term was changed, and the time for holding the Epiphany Quarter Sessions was fixed, under the advice of the late Lord Abinger, then Sir James Scarlett. The Bill proposed by the hon. Gentleman would not prevent senior barristers from attending quarter-sessions, but it would prevent the possibility of their juniors being present at the commencement of term in Westminster-hall. And if there was one thing more important than another with respect to that branch of practice, it was that the gentlemen who had been concerned in cases at the quarter-sessions should have an opportunity of arguing those cases, on appeal, before Her Majesty's Judges in Westminster-hall. And when the hon. Gentleman suggested an alteration in the commencement of Hilary Term, he thought the House would pause before it sanctioned the alteration of an arrangement which had been so well considered, and had been found, altogether, to work so well. Many great and lasting inconveniences would result from any alteration of the present arrangement, to say nothing of prisoners being detained a week longer before trial.

MR. PACKE , in reply, said, he was free to confess that he did not see the force of the objections which had been urged against the Bill. No man acknowledged the efficiency of the bar more readily than himself, and he should be sorry to promote any me

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Poor Law | tithe | municipal | 2 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-025 | 1850 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Alfred Hervey | Mr. Octavius Duncombe | Mr. Pole Carew | Mr. Cobden | Mr. Spooner | Mr. Card | Mr. Christy | Mr. Hume
Outcome:     Motion: Bill read | Motion: passed on | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: carried on | Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: resolved in
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Day for further considering the Report | Lord Clanricarde and the Post | Motions on the Paper | Motion he had on the Paper | Motions which stood on the Paper | Bate in Aid Bill where it stood on the Paper
Division:    Ayes 85, Noes 43 | Ayes 125, Noes 46
Hansard:     S3V0101P0 | S3V0102P0 | S3V0104P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

2° Labouring Poor (Ireland).

Reported .—Sheep, &c. Contagious Diseases Prevention.

3° and passed:—Militia Pay; Out Pensioners; Sheep, &c., Importation Prohibition; Tithe Kent Charge, &c. (Ireland) (No. 2).

PETITIONS PRESENTED. By Sir R. H. Inglis, from the Town of Youghal, and its Vicinity, for declaring the Agitation for Repeal of the Union with Ireland to be High Treason.—By Lord Alfred Hervey, from Inhabitants of Brighton, for Adoption of Vote by Ballot.—By Sir R. H. Inglis, from the Village of Wolvey, Warwickshire, for Discouragement of Idolatry in India.—By Mr. Octavius Duncombe, from the Township of Hawes, Yorkshire, for a Better Observance of the Lord's Day.—By Mr. Pole Carew, from several Persons connected with the Mines in Cornwall, against the Copper and Lead Duties Bill.—By Mr. Cobden, from the Inhabitants of Henley-upon-Thames, Oxford, in favour of a Revision of Taxation.—By Mr. Spooner, from the Trustees of the Rugby Charity, for Exemption from the Charitable Trust Regulations Bill.—By Dr. Bowring, from Inhabitants of Heywood, Lancashire, in favour of Secular Education.—By Mr. Card well, from the Proprietors of Bedford New Mills, in the Parish of Leigh, Lancashire, for an Alteration of the Factories Act.—By Mr. Christy, 145 from Alexander Isbister, for Inquiry into the Conduct of the Hudson's Bay Company.—By Mr. Cobden, from Robert MacTaggart, late Schoolmaster under the Poor Law Board at Norwood Pauper Industrial School, for Inquiry respecting his Case.—By S

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Tithe | Poor Law | duchy | Railway | railway | 2 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-026 | 1850 | s.3 | NEEDS_REVIEW
================================================================
Status:      NEEDS_REVIEW
MP/Lord:     Not extracted
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S3V0102P0
Journals:    nan

COMBINED CONTEXT: [No wide-context passage available — see existing knowledge report]

FORENSIC NOTES:
None
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-027 | 1851 | s.3 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Henn | Mr. Napier | Mr. Hamilton | Mr. Twisleton | Earl of Harrowby | Lord Howden | Mr. Hood | Lord Ponsouby
Outcome:     Motion: House agreed | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: carried on | Motion: carried by | Motion: Bill read | Motion: passed by | Motion: House resolved | Motion: passed without
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: In a letter which appeared in the Times
Division:    Ayes 23, Noes 97 | Ayes 50, Noes 125 | Ayes 103, Noes 170 | Ayes 24, Noes 72 | Ayes 43, Noes 80 | Ayes 21, Noes 90 | Ayes 14, Noes 107 | Ayes 52, Noes 2
Hansard:     S3V0107P0 | S3V0108P0 | S3V0109P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_106

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

MR. M. J. O'CONNELL said, his hon. Friends who had opposed the original clause saw the evils which that clause had produced, but they did not see the greater evils which that clause had prevented. He was satisfied that if an unlimited right to relief had been given, without requiring a surrender of land, the Consolidated Fund itself would not have satisfied the claims which would have been made. The doubts which had arisen respecting the working of the quarter-acre clause, as it was termed, had been brought before an eminent barrister, Mr. Henn, who gave it as his opinion that a legal surrender of the land was not necessary; that all that was required was cessation to occupy. But other doubts had since sprung up, and he thought it was the duty of the House now to clear them up. He hoped the Government would come forward and settle the law upon this subject.

MR. POULETT SCROPE said, this was a new ejectment clause. He thought the evil of the quarter-acre clause was that persons applying for relief were required to surrender the whole of the land they occupied, with the house they lived in: he did not think the operation of the law would be so much complained of if parties were only required to surrender the surplus of the land they held, and were allowed to retain their house and a quarter of an acre.

SIR L. O'BRIEN said, that the language which had been used in that House upon the subject of Ireland by the hon. Member 82 for Stroud, had done more to sow dissension in that 

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Poor Law | tithe | Tithe | Turnpike | election | Railway | 4 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-028 | 1852 | s.3 | NEEDS_REVIEW
================================================================
Status:      NEEDS_REVIEW
MP/Lord:     Not extracted
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S3V0111P0, S3V0113P0, S3V0115P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_107

COMBINED CONTEXT: [No wide-context passage available — see existing knowledge report]

FORENSIC NOTES:
Speaker's certificate referenced; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-029 | 1853 | Unknown | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Mowatt | Mr. Lushington | Lord Dudley Stuart | Mr. Barry | Lord Seymour | Lord Denman | Lord Palmerston | Lord Lyndhurst
Outcome:     Motion: Bill read | Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill introduced | Motion: passed by | Motion: Bill passed
Defendant:   had answered | or his | in substance | and immediately | to amend | to and | and also | in support
Publication: Committee in their Report | Parliamentary Papers | Address based on the Report | Dublin University Magazine | Lord went anywhere he would go to the Times | He was informed that the Dublin Times | With regard to the Dublin Times | The Standard
Division:    Ayes 55, Noes 24 | Ayes 137, Noes 229 | Ayes 125, Noes 136 | Ayes 40, Noes 169
Hansard:     S3V0117P0 | S3V0119P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_108

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

SIR JOHN JOHNSTONE, as one of those connected with a large water company in the metropolis, had looked forward with great anxiety to the Government Bill 231 of the present Session. He wished to state to the House that the present measure was entirely the production of the Government, without reference to any of the companies, none of whom, as far as he knew, had been asked for suggestions. He approved of the general principles proposed to regulate the water supply, and he would remind the House that it was very nearly the precise plan which he (Sir J. Johnstone) had suggested when the Government Bill was first introduced. Some of the provision might be productive of harm, but, as they would have to be submitted to a Select Committee, he would not offer any further remarks on the subject.

Leave given.

Bill ordered to be brought in by Mr. Mowatt, Mr. Lushington, and Lord Dudley Stuart.

Bill read 1°.

MR. BERNAL OSBORNE, in moving "that Dr. Reid be called to the Bar of the House and questioned as to the means at his disposal for ventilating the New Buildings," said, that a good supply of air was even more important than a good supply of water, and his present Motion more nearly affected hon. Members than that last under discussion, for it related to the supply of fresh air to this House. Assuredly nothing could be worse than the present state of the ventilation. It was suggested that the subject should be referred to a Committee, but he had strong objections to any such cour

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: election | Election | Poor Law | trespass | municipal | Municipal | corn law | Returning Officer | 5 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Stockdale v Hansard case; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-030 | 1860 | Unknown | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Speaker | Lord Beau | Duke of Nor | Earl of Long | Earl of Longford | Baron Sil | Viscount 
Payment | Viscount Lorton
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Returns are made up in the last Report
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     None
Journals:    HCJ_volume_115

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):
East India 
Stock Trans- 
fer, &amp;c. Bill 


Prisons (Scot- 
land) Bill. 


Lands Clauses 
Consolidation 
Acts (1845) 
Amendment 
Bill. 


Maynooth 
College Bill. 


Hamilton and 
Strathaven 
Railway Bili 
[Lerds.] 





486 


were jointly receiving Education at the Period to 
which the Returns are made up in the last Report 
of the Education Commissioners, and the Number 
of Protestant and Roman Catholic Children in each 
such School respectively. 


Ordered, That there be laid before this House, 
a Copy of the Regulations made by the Board of 
Trinity College, Dubiin, for placing the Names of 
Masters and Doctors on the College Books, in pur- 
suance of the Queen’s Letters Patent of the 24th 
day of July 1857: And, Return of the Number 
of Persons who have availed themselves of that 
Privilege ; distinguishing those who have been ad- 
mitted Free and those on the payment of Fees. 





Ordered, That there be laid before this House, a 
Cop; of the Correspondence, Surveys, and Commis- 
sioners’ Reports in reference to the Queen’s Gap in 
the Lax Weir at Limerick since the Fishery Board 
was appointed, and more particularly since the 
Complaint of Lords Shannon and Clonbruck was 
made in 1851. 


A Message was delivered by Colonel Clifford, 

Yeoman Usher of the Black Rod : 
Mr. Speaker, 

The Lords, authorized by virtue of Her Majesty’s 
Commission, for declaring Her Royal Assent to 
several Acts agreed upon by both Houses, desire 
the immediate attendance of this Honourab

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | Poor Law | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-031 | 1864 | Unknown | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Bruce | Sir George Grey | Mr. Dalglish | Mr. Buchanan | Mr. Crum | Mr. Bovill | Mr. 
Macaulay | Mr. Walter
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Copy of the Report | Copies of any Papers | Bank Post | Stamp Duty on Bank Post
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     None
Journals:    HCJ_volume_119

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):



























































272 


The College of Physicians Bill was, according to 
Order, read a second time ; and committed toa 
Committee of the whole House, for this day. 


College of 
Physicians 
Bill. 


Chief Rents The Order of the day being read, for taking into 
Corde) Bill consideration the Chief Rents (Ireland) Bill, as 
; amended in the Committee ; 
Ordered, That the Bill be taken into considera- 
tion upon Friday next. 


Coventry Ordered, That leave be given to bring in a Bill 
Free Grammar for confirming a Scheme of the Charity Commis- 
aioners for the Charity called “The Free Gram- 
mar School,” in the City of Coventry: And that 
Mr. Bruce and Sir George Grey do prepare, and 


bring it in. 


Sale of Gas 


Ordered, That leave be given to bring in a Bill 
(Scotland. ) 


to enable Parliamentary Burghs (being Royal 
Burghs) in Scotland to avail themselves of the 
Provisions of the Acts twenty-second and twenty- 
third Victoria, chapter sixty-six, and twenty-third 
and twenty-fourth Victoria, chapter one hundred 
and forty-six, for regulating the Sale of Gas: And 
that Mr. Dalglish, Mr. Buchanan and Mr. Crum- 


Ewing do prepare, and bring it in. 


Burials Regis- 


Ordered, That leave be given to bring in a Bill 
tration. 


to make further Provisions for the Registration of 
Burials in England: And that Mr. Bovill, Mr. 
Macaulay and Mr. Walter do prepare, and bring 
it in. 


Highways Act The Select Committee on the Highways 

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | Turnpike | Stamp Duty | 5 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-032 | 1874 | Unknown | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. William Henry | Mr. Bourke | Mr. Speaker | Mr. Russe | Sir John Kennaway | Mr. Dillwyn | Mr. Richard Shaw
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: That the said Paper
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     None
Journals:    HCJ_volume_129

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):
Public Several Public Petitions were presented, and 
Petitions. read; and ordered to lie upon the Table. 
Vide Twenty- 


second Report. 


Public Health Ordered, That the Return relative to the Pub- 


Act (1872.) lic Health Act (1872), which was presented upon 
No. 304. the 16th day of this instant July, be printed. 

East India Ordered, That the Return relative to East 

(Bombay India ( Bombay Riots), which was presented upon 

— 905 the 16th day of this instant July, be printed. 

ule of Man. Ordered That the Accounts relative to the Js/e 
No. 306. 2 Man, which were presented upon the 16th day 

‘"" of this instant July, be printed. 

Habitual Mr. William Henry Smith presented,— Return 

Criminals to an Order, dated the 11th day of May last, for 

Registration. 4 Return relative to Habitual Criminals Registra- 


tion. 


National Debt § Return to an Order, dated the 21st day of May 


(1857-8 to last, for a Return relative to the National Debt, 
es 1857-8 to 1873-4. 

No. 307. 
PublicExpendi- Return to an Order, dated the 21st day of May 
ture (Ex- last, for a Return relative to Public Expenditure 
—— Issues) (Amount of Public Expenditure charged on 

arge on 

Taxes.—1857- Votes). . ’ 
8 to 1873-4, Ordered, That the said Returns do lie upon the 
changed from 


Ament Table; and that the two last be printed. 
Public Expenditure charged on Votes.) 


No. 308. 
North America Mr. Bourke presented, by Her Majesty’s Com- 
_ 1, 1874.) mand,—Copy of Correspondence with the Gove

FORENSIC NOTES:
1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-033 | 1875 | s.1 | PARTIAL
================================================================
Status:      PARTIAL
MP/Lord:     Mr. Dyke | Mr. Rowland Winn | Mr. Richard Power | Mr. Gibson | Viscount Crich Saath | Mr. Speaker | Mr. Raikes
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     None
Journals:    HCJ_volume_130

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):
Question proposed, That those words be there 
added :— Amendment, by leave, withdrawn. 

Another Amendment proposed, at the end of the 
Clause, to add the words “ Provided always, That 
“ the Judge may, if he shall so think fit, empannel a 
“ Jury of not more than nine, nor less than five, to 
“* be taken by ballot from the Jury’s panel for 
* such assizes, who may vary. or alter the amount 
*‘ of compensation presented by the Grand Jury, 
“ and the area in which the same may have been 
** assessed.” : 

Question proposed, That those words be there 
added :—Amendment, by leave, withdrawn. 

Clause, as amended, agreed to. 


CiausE N° 4 (Continuance of 2 &amp; 3 Vgc. c¢. 74, 
as amended by 11 &amp; 12 Vic. c. 89.) f 
Amendment proposed, in p. 4, 1. li, to leave 
out the words “ as amended by the Act passed in 
“ the Session of Parliament held in the eleventh and 


“ twelfth 


















—F 





‘Protection of Life and Property in certain Parts 


38 Vicrortia. 


“ twelfth yearsof the reign of Her present Majesty, 
“ chapter seventy-nine.” 

Question put, That the words proposed to be 
left out stand part of the Clause ; 

The Committee divided. 

Tellers for the { Mr. Dyke, 7} 


Yeas, Mr. Rowland Winn: J 101. 
Tellers for the {Captain Nolan, l 68 
Noes, \Mr. Richard Power: J : 


An Amendment made. 
Another Amendment proposed, in p. 4,1. 21, to 
leave out the word “ eighty,” in order to insert 
the words “‘ seventy-seven.” 
Question put, That the word “eighty” stand 

FORENSIC NOTES:
3 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-034 | 1884 | Unknown | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Not extracted
Outcome:     Motion: Bill passed
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Vide Post
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     None
Journals:    HCJ_volume_139

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

read a second time, 219. Committed, 228. Reported 
from Select Committee on Police aud Sanitary Regula- 
tions, 282. Considered, as amended, 308, Queen’s Consent 
signified ; Bill passed, with Amendments, 319. ‘lo which 
the Lords agree, 327. (Cited as Belfast Improvement 
Act, 1884) Royal Assent, 335. 


Beirast Junction Rattway. Vide BauiycriaRe. 
Beurast Mait Service. Vide Post Orrice. 
Bera: T (Queen’s Colleges). Vide Accounts. 


Bevrast, Straxptown, and Higu Worywoop Raitway; 


Report, That the Bill should originate in the House of 
Lords, 30. Report, That the Standing Orders had been 
certified to have been complied with, 83. Bill brought 
from the Lords, 111. Read, and referred to the Examiners 
of Petitions for Private Bills, 11:. Report, That the 
Standing Orders not previously inquired into have been 
complied with; Bill to be read a second time, 118. 
Committed, 131. The Chairman of Ways and Means 


a 
——————E 


dischargod from attendance on the Committee; another 
Member appointed Chairman, 155. Reported, without 
Amendment, 155. Considered, 163. Passed, 170, 
(Cited as Belfast, Straudtown, and Holywood Railway 
ad ( Extension of Time) Act, 1884) Royal Assent, 
186. 


Bevrast Street Tramways; Report, That the Bill should 


originate in the House of Lords, 30. Report, That the 
Standing Orders had been certified to have been cowplied 
with, 83. Bill brought from the Lords, 236. Read, and 
referred to the Examiners of Petitions for Private Bills, 
236. Report

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | Election | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-035 | 1887 | Unknown | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Duke of Connaught | Mr. Speaker | Mr. Ditton | Sir Charles 
Lewis
Outcome:     Motion: Motion Withdrawn | Motion: resolved in
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     None
Journals:    HCJ_volume_142

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):
Highness the Duke of Connaught to return to England 
for a limited time, for the purpose of being present at the 
celebration of Her Majesty’s Jubilee, without thereby resign- 
ing his Command in Bombay; Ordered ; presented, 176. 
Second Reading deferred, 182, 185, 189, 193,195, 198, 201, 
204, 210, 212, 215,218,222. Motion, That the Bill be now 
read a second time ; Amendment proposed, “ Six Months,” 
but, on Division, not made; Bill committed, 232. Com- 
mittee deferred, 2:38, 242, 252. Bull considered in Com- 
mittee, and reported, without Amendment; passed, 257. 
Agreed to by the Lords,260. Royal Assent, 261. 


Vide Ways and Mzans. 
Vide Ways and 
Means (Bills of Supply). 
— (No. 2) Bint. Vide Ways and 

Means ( Bills of Supply). 

—_—_—_——_—_—— ( Appropriation) Bitt. Vide Ways 
and Means ( Bills of Supply). 
(Abstract Account fur 1885, 1886). 


the private interveution of Mr. Speaker prove ineffectual, | Constanies’ Pensions. Vide Pouice. 


to repress all disorders in the bbies as in the House 


itsel’”; Amendment and Motion Withdrawn, 389. ConstaBucary, &amp;c., Beurast. Vide MuNIcIPAL. 


ConstTaBuLary Foror Funp (Jreland). Vide Accounts. 
ConstaBuLArY Force (Jreland). Vide SurPty. 
ConstaBuLaRy (Jreland). Vide Royrat. 

ConsuLar EsTaBLisHMENTS ABROAD. Vide SupPLy. 
ConraGious Disgases Acts (Egypt). Vide Accounts. 


Contacious Diseases (Animals) Act, 1878 and 1884. 
Vide Accounts. 


— Mr. Ditton and the “Times” News- 
PAPER; Complaint made to the House by Sir Cha

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: MuNIcIPAL | Election | ELEction | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-036 | 1888 | Unknown | DEBUNKED
================================================================
Status:      DEBUNKED
MP/Lord:     Not extracted
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     None
Journals:    HCJ_volume_143

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):
—— (Statement of Trade). 
(Statistical Abstract). Vide Accounts. 


—— —— (Taylor, Mr. W.). 
and Means (Amendments). 


(Telegraph Department). 


Vide Accounts. 





Vide Accounts. Ways 


Vide Accounts. 


(Upper Burmah) (Intoxicating Liquors) ; 
(Licences); (Opium). Vide Accounts. 








Vide Norru Sea. 


EccvestAsticaL AssgEssMENTS (Scotland); Bill to amend 


the Law as to Lcclesiastical Assessments in Scotland ; 
Ordered, 14. Presented, 19. Second Reading deferred, 
358, 380. Order for Second Reading discharged; Bill 
withdrawn, 398. 

———_—- —_——-_ Motion, That, in 


the opinion of this House, it is inexpedient that Assess- 


ments for Ecclesiastical purposes in Scutland should be 
maintained, and that in lieu thereof an equivalent annual! 
assessment Ought to be made for assisting Secondary 
Education in Scotland; Amendment proposed, to leave 
out from the word “ That,” to the end of the Question, in 
order to add the words “‘as the Ecclesiastical Assess- 
ments have been a burden upon land from time imme- 
morial for the erection and repair of church buildings in 
the old parishes of Scotland, this House, in the absence 
of any grievance connected therewith, except in the 
case of feuars, for whose relief a Bill is now before 
Parliament, declines to entertain a proposal to alienate 
these assessments to secular uses”; and, on Division, 

made: 


L 2 





INDEX Zo the Ont Hunprep and Forry-tairp Voiume. 


EccuestasticaL AssessMENTS (Scotlund)—continued. 
mad

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: ELECTION | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-037 | 1890 | Unknown | PARTIAL
================================================================
Status:      PARTIAL
MP/Lord:     Not extracted
Outcome:     Motion: Bill passed
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     None
Journals:    HCJ_volume_145

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):
Considered in Committee, 218. Committee deferred, 223, 
— considered in Committee, 227, 231. Committee 
deferred, 236, 253. Baill further considered in Committee, 
and reported, without Amendment; Passed, 256. 
to by the Lords, 286. (Cited as South Indian Railway 
Purchase Act, 1890) Royal Assent, 283. Vide supra. 


( Statement of Trade). Vide Accounts. 
— (Statistical Abstract). Vide Accounts. 


Easton and Cuurcu Hope Raitway; Petition, and Bill 
ordered, 28. Read, and referred to the Examiners, 49. 
Report, That Standing Order 62 has been complied with; 
Bill to be read a second time, 188. Committed, 200. 
Reported, 232. Considered, as amended, 284. Queen’s 
Consent signified; Bill passed, 301. Agreed to by the 
Lords, 475. (Cited as Easton and Church Hope Railway 
Act, 1890) Royal Assent, 510. 


East Ripine Raitway. Vide BeveRLey. 


East 








VS = VS mee OD DO DM 


- 


—-—- Eo 


a: i a ee er es 


&lt;= 


58 &amp; 64 Vicr.] INDEX to the One Hunorep and Forty-rirra Voiume. 





East StongHouse Locat Boarp; Report on Petition for 
Jeave to deposit a Petition for a Bill, That the Standing 
Orders ought to be dispensed with, 374. Report, That 
the Standing Orders have not been complied with; re- 
ferred to the Select Committee on Standing Orders, 
438. Petition for Bill, reterred to the said Committee, 
446. Report, That the Standing Orders ought to be dis- 
pensed with, 451. Report read; Bill ordered, 454. Read, 
and referred to the Examiners, 460. Order, referri

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-038 | 1892 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Brunner | Mr. Neville | Mr. Mattinson | Mr. Forwood | Mr. Picton | Lord John Russell | Lord Stanley | Mr. Speaker
Outcome:     Motion: carried by | Motion: passed by | Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: Bill read
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: I will refer to a Report | The Report | I referred to the Report | Tory Report | But not eight Tories when the Report
Division:    Ayes 209, Noes 172 | Ayes 215, Noes 147
Hansard:     S4V0001P0 | S4V0004P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Order for Second Reading to-morrow read, and discharged.

Bill withdrawn.

On Motion of Sir M. Hicks Beach, Bill to confirm certain Provisional Orders made by the Board of Trade, under "The General Pier and Harbour Act, 1861," relating to Killala, Stornoway, Sutherland, and Torquay, ordered to be brought in by Sir M. Hicks Beach and Sir J. Gorst.

Bill presented, and read first time. [Bill 335.]

On Motion of Mr. Brunner, Bill to amend "The Municipal Corporations Act, 1882," ordered to be brought in by Mr. Brunner, Mr. Neville, Mr. T. P. O'Connor, and Dr. Commins.

Bill presented, and read first time. [Bill 336.]

House adjourned at half after Twelve o'clock.

Mr. SPEAKER was in his place shortly after Twelve o'clock, but not until twenty-five minutes before One o'clock, and after attention had been called to the number of Members present, was a quorum found.

Order for Second Reading read.

*(11.40.) MR. MATTINSON (Liverpool, Walton) : I had hoped that the good sense and fairness of principle upon which the Bill is founded would have enabled the Second Reading to pass without any opposition. But I find notices of opposition have been given from more than one quarter, and therefore I must say a few words as to the object of the measure and the necessity for it. The object is to amend the Municipal Corporations Act in the direction of removing a difficulty—a serious difficulty I allow, but a senseless difficulty, and one founded on no principle in the way of the re-adjustment

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Municipal | municipal | election | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-039 | 1892 | s.3 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Smith | Mr. Ponsonby | Mr. Jackson | Mr. Andrew Kettle | Mr. Gladstone | Mr. Dillon | Lord Chief Baron | Mr. Redmond
Outcome:     Motion: Bill introduced | Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill read | Motion: passed without | Motion: Motion agreed
Defendant:   describes is
Publication: Irish Times | A letter appeared in the Irish Times | First Report | Parliamentary Paper
Division:    Ayes 174, Noes 229 | Ayes 228, Noes 14
Hansard:     S4V0001P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

* MR. SHAW LEFEVRE: I am coming to that shortly. The great bulk of the landlords on whose estates evictions had taken place had made no proposals to their tenants. The tenants had been most anxious for a settlement, and had done their very best to induce the landlords to offer them terms. In other cases the landlords made offers of such a character that it could not be expected for a moment that the tenants would avail themselves of them. What was the case of the Olphert estate? The evicted tenants, 340 in number, approached their landlord through Father Boyle, the curate of Falcarragh, and asked for terms of purchase. Colonel Olphert, in reply, said he was prepared to sell his lands if the tenants would pay in cash at once a sum representing the rent of the three years they had been out of possession, and also 20 years' purchase of the land. I venture to say that these terms were practically prohibitive, at id could only have been brought forward in the belief that they would prevent further negotiations. What was the case on the Ponsonby estate? I know 1682 something about it, for I have had communications from the excellent priest, Canon Keller, of Youghal. The offer made by the hon. Member for South Hunts (Mr. Smith-Barry)—who acts as chairman of the syndicate which has taken over this estate—I am sorry to say, hardly carried out the promise of his speech in the House. One would have expected that he would be one of the first to consider the subject in a conciliatory man

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: election | Election | Railway | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-040 | 1895 | Unknown | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Lieutenant | Lord Advocate | Sir Charles Tupper | Duke of Leinster | Lord Kilmorey | Mr. Harrabin | Mr. Sadleir
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: The Labour Gazette | Secretary for Scotland when the Report | The Report | Belfast Post | I have been unable to obtain a specific Report
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S4V0020P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

MR. BARTLEY : I beg to ask the Secretary of State for War whether he can state the number of soldiers' billets during the last six months, the total amount paid, and the average payment per man per day, and per horse per day, to the licensed victuallers on whom the troops were billeted?

* THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR WAR (Mr. CAMPBELL-BANNERMAN, Stirling, &c.) : This information would have to he collected from a great many accounts and would take some time to compile. If the hon. Member sees any public advantage in the Return, and will move for it, I shall be happy to give him the information up to the latest date for which accounts have been received—probably the 30th of September.

MR. BARTLEY : I beg to ask the Vice President of the Committee of Council on Education if he can state whether there has been a substantial increase in the number of evening schools this winter in consequence of the new Regulations?

* THE VICE PRESIDENT OF THE COUNCIL (Mr. ACLAND, York, W.R., Rotherham ) : The number of evening schools claiming grant has risen this winter from just under 2,000 to considerably over 8,000.

MR. DODD : I beg to ask the First Commissioner of Works whether the Agricultural Commission proposes to inquire into the practicability of the establishment of district markets in London for agricultural produce by the Railway Companies and the Local Authorities conjointly, and to consider what legislation is necessary to effect that purpose if found desirable; if not, whether 

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | railway | election | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-041 | 1897 | Unknown | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Duke of Devonshire | Duke of Westminster | Mr. Disraeli | Earl of Selborne | Viscount Wolmer | Sir Humphrey Edwin | Lord Mayor | Lord Mansfield
Outcome:     Motion: Bill passed | Motion: Bill read | Motion: passed by | Motion: carried on | Motion: passed without | Motion: Bill introduced | Motion: carried without
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: An Amendment on the Paper | Life and Times | What did they say in their Report | Act based on the Report | In the Report | If the Report | LEOD asked where that was stated in the Report | Thirteenth Annual Report
Division:    Ayes 100, Noes 148 | Ayes 80, Noes 144 | Ayes 188, Noes 147 | Ayes 239, Noes 177 | Ayes 179, Noes 192 | Ayes 149, Noes 169
Hansard:     S4V0033P0 | S4V0034P0 | S4V0035P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

MR. BRYNMOR JONES (Gloucester, Stroud) asked the Secretary to the Treasury whether he could give an assurance that the grant of £3,000 to the University of Wales would be continued. He asked the question because a very important meeting of the governing body of the University would be held to-morrow, and because the Vote for the University was not included in the Estimates. [ Cries of "Order!"] It was understood that the late Government would have brought in a Supplementary Estimate on the subject.

MR. AKERS-DOUGLAS said, he was afraid he could not give the hon. Member any assurance on the matter until the Leader of the House was in his place.

SIR WILFRID LAWSON (Cumberland, Cockermouth) : Mr. Speaker, before the Adjournment of the House I wish to give notice that early next Session—[ Cries of "Order!"]—I shall move— "That, in the opinion of this House, the legislative power of all existing peers should be abolished—[ Loud laughter ]— and that no such power should henceforth he conferred on any persons not popularly elected." [ Cheers and laughter. ]

House adjourned at Twenty-five minutes before Four o'clock.

Reported from the Select Committee with Amendments.

THE LORD PRIVY SEAL (Viscount CROSS) said, he had to present a Petition of some importance from the Darlington School. Board praying that— "in the interests of education and economy, as well as justice and religious freedom, all efficient public elementary schools, whether voluntary or board, are entitled to large

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: election | Election | tithe | railway | Railway | trespass | Friendly Society | municipal | 7 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-042 | 1898 | Unknown | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Lieutenant | Mr. Mallon | Mr. Lewin Hill | Mr. Hill | Lord Tweedmouth | Mr. Justice | Mr. Justice Bewley | Lord Brassey
Outcome:     Motion: Bill read | Motion: passed by | Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill passed
Defendant:   should have
Publication: General Post | Home Office on the Report | Departmental Committee on the Post | House of Commons Paper | Eleventh Report | LORD HARRIS moved that the Report | There was also a minority Report | They hurried up an interim Report
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S4V0040P0 | S4V0042P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

MR. STANLEY LEIGHTON (Shropshire, Oswestry) : I beg to ask the Vice-President of the Committee of Council on Education, whether the managers of a voluntary school held under an ordinary trust deed made in accordance with the School Sites Acts will be able, under Clause 25, to borrow from the county councils?

THE VICE PRESIDENT OF THE COUNCIL (Sir JOHN GORST, Cambridge University) : Yes; they are subject to the provisions of the Charity Trustees Act.

MR. F. A. CHANNING (Northampton, E.) : I beg to ask the Secretary to the Treasury, as representing the Postmaster General, whether he is aware that, previous to the taking over of the telephone wires by the Government, subscribers to the National Telephone Company in Kettering were charged threepence for three minutes' conversation between Kettering and Leicester, but that since the Government has taken over the trunk wires the Company has given notice that the charge will be increased to sixpence; and, whether, having regard to the large amount of transactions thus carried out between these towns, he will take steps to have the old tariff of charges retained.

MR. HANBURY : The Company, after acquiring various telephone systems throughout the country, were gradually adopting a uniform scale of charges for trunk conversations. That scale gives 6d. as the rate between Kettering and Leicester, and in explanation of the fact that only 3d. was being charged, the Postmaster General supposes that the company had not had the time to a

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | Election | Land Tax | Municipal | 2 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-043 | 1899 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Rossas Land | Mr. Justice Ross | Mr. Justice Monroe | Mr. Rice | Mr. Justice Harrison | Mr. Justice | Mr. Justice Munroe | Mr. Munroe
Outcome:     Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill read
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Dublin Gazette | The Report | As regarded the Report | Ogilvie in his Report | Gentleman of a paragraph in the Report | Amendments on the Paper
Division:    Ayes 47, Noes 16
Hansard:     S4V0043P0 | S4V0044P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

MR. WHITE said he was very glad to see that generally politics had not much to do with Education in Scotland. They had Voluntary Schools, but they had no trouble with them He congratulated the Scotch Education Department on the Minute they had issued and the spirit and intention shown in it. It might 239 interest the House to know that a Committee was appointed by the Secondary and Technical Education Association of Scot land to consider the whole Question, and he had the honour of drafting the Report of that Committee, which was indorsed by the Association. The Report anticipated by six or eight months the recommendations of the Royal Commission on Secondary Education. The idea in the Minute of the Department appeared to be, to have two different bodies, the Borough and the County Committee, to administer Secondary Education, and he would like to know to what extent there had been any response to the spirit and intention of the Minute. He would like to ask how the Government were carrying out the Minute in the case of counties in which there were a great many police burghs. Then he would like to ask, because it was not stated in the Minute, whether the funds for secondary and technical education were to be kept apart, as they were now, al though they were distributed by the body. He specially put this matter of the distribution of the grant before the Lord Advocate for this reason, that the right hon. Gentleman admitted that in some of the towns in Scotland too much money w

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Election | election | Municipal | Returning Officer | 2 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-044 | 1900 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Earl of Durham | Mr. Balfour | Mr. Secretary Chamberlain | Sir Matthew White | Mr. Asquith | Mr. Jesse Collings | Mr. Sydney Buxton | Mr. Fisher
Outcome:     Motion: agreed on
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Act shall apply to money invested in the Post
Division:    Ayes 107, Noes 31
Hansard:     S4V0051P0 | S4V0053P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

*MR. STUART-WORTLEY could not allow such a remark as that to pass unchallenged. Without some such Amendment as this it would be to the obvious interest of the employer to leave the workman to find for himself as best he could such comforts and payments as might be necessary in his wounded condition until such time as he could get his claim for compensation settled. The Amendment was, therefore, in the interest of the employé.

*MR.J. WILSON (Durham, Mid.) said this Amendment was brought forward in that House by the hon. Baronet the Member for Chester-le-Street, but was refused by the Government. The Earl of Durham brought it forward in another place, and it was there accepted by the Government. He regarded it as another concession to the employers, in order to make it less detestable to them. Lords' Amendment agreed to. Lords' Amendments agreed to; insert as a fresh sub-section: "(3.) Where a workman has given notice of an accident, he shall, if so required by the employer, submit himself for examination by a 1675 duly qualified medical practitioner provided and paid. by the employer, and if he refuses to submit himself to such examination, or in any way obstructs the same, his right to compensation, and. any proceeding under this Act in relation to compensation, shall be suspended until such examination takes place." In sub-section (8) leave nut "to any registrar." In sub-section (9) leave out "under" and insert "from" and leave out "paid into" and insert "invested in." In 

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: friendly society | Election | Municipal | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-045 | 1903 | Unknown | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Cohen | Mr. Hanbury | Lord Balfour | Mr. Gedge | Mr. Randell | Mr. Bennett | Mr. Delabere | Earl of Northbrook
Outcome:     Motion: carried on | Motion: Motion negatived | Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: Bill passed
Defendant:   while the | in one | and whether
Publication: Annual Report | Archbishop of York had a Motion on the Paper | SPEAKER laid upon the Table Report | I deny that the Report | I readily surrendered my place on the Paper | Consular Report | Scotland will present to Parliament a Report | I have seen the statement in the Report
Division:    Ayes 242, Noes 130 | Ayes 95, Noes 85 | Ayes 138, Noes 183
Hansard:     S4V0067P0 | S4V0070P0 | S4V0072P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Order read for resuming Adjourned Debate on Question [20th February], "That a Select Committee be appointed to inquire into the powers of charge conferred by Parliament on the Metropolitan Gas Companies, and to report as to the method in which those powers have been exercised, having regard to the differences of price charged by the various Companies.—( Mr. Cohen. )

Question again proposed.

And, it being midnight, the Debate stood adjourned.

Debate to be resumed this day.

Second Reading deferred till Thursday.

Second Reading deferred till Monday next.

Committee deferred till Monday next.

Second Reading deferred till Thursday.

Second Reading deferred till Wednesday 15th March.

Second Reading deferred till Monday next.

Considered in Committee.

(In the Committee.)

Committee report Progress; to sit again this day.

Committe to consider of authorising the issue out of the Consolidated Fund of sums for the improvement of Telephonic Communication (Queen's Recommendation signified) To-morrow.—( Mr. Hanbury. )

House adjourned at Five minutes past Twelve of the clock.

THE LORD CHANCELLOR took his seat upon the Woolsack at Four of the clock.

THE LORD CHANCELLOR acquainted the House that the Clerk of the Parliaments had laid upon the Table the Certificates from the Examiners that the further Standing Orders applicable to the following Bills have been complied with—

Southport Tramways [H.L.]

Hull, Barnsley, and West Riding Junction Railway and Dock [H.L.]

North-Eastern 

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | election | municipal | tithe | railway | Election | trespass | 4 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-046 | 1904 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Advocate | Lord Lieutenant | Mr. Samuel Evans | Mr. Costelloe | Mr. Cassell | Mr. Mac | Mr. Caldwell | Lord Stanmore
Outcome:     Motion: passed by | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: Bill read | Motion: carried on
Defendant:   is endeavouring | in the
Publication: Amendment lower down on the Paper | Amendments lower down an the Paper | Gentleman is afraid of the Report | The Times | There is an Amendment standing in the Paper | Member for Wigtonshire said of a Report | Chairman left the Chair to make his Report | Ordinance of Ceylon from the Government Gazett
Division:    Ayes 258, Noes 160 | Ayes 165, Noes 262 | Ayes 18, Noes 80 | Ayes 26, Noes 72
Hansard:     S4V0074P0 | S4V0075P0 | S4V0076P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

* MR. WEIR : With regard to the holidays given on board the cruisers, it is not a matter of an hour, or a week, or a month, but of very considerable periods every year. The commanders are servants of the Fishery Board, and we are entitled to know whether the cruisers were at work or simply lying in harbour. We ought to know how the taxpayers' money is expended, and, as a protest, I beg to move the reduction of Item A by £100.

Motion made, and Question put—

"That Item A (Salaries) be reduced by £100."—( Mr.Weir. )

The Committee divided:—Ayes, 18; Noes, 80. (Division List, No. 270.)

MR. CALDWELL (Lanarkshire, Mid.) : I cannot allow this Vote to pass without moving a reduction in respect of the sum taken from Scotland under it. I am glad the Chancellor of the Exchequer is here. The position is this, that he has given on the Scottish Vote £10,000 a year less out the Imperial funds than last year. I protest against that. This is not an isolated case, as the Chancellor of the Exchequer knows. For Highland works we used to get £20,000 a year, and now it is reduced to £10,000, at the very time when you are adding to the Vote to Ireland for agriculture and technical education £75,000, and £25,000 under the Congested District Board Bill, which has just been introduced. I protest that while the Government is taking £10,000 from Scotland they are pouring by the two Bills before the House £100,000 into Ireland in addition to what they gave Ireland last year. I move the reduction of t

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: tithe | election | land tax | railway | Railway | Tithe | Poor Law | LAND TAX | 5 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-047 | 1906 | s.3 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Mac | Lord Salisbury | Lord Roberts | Mr. Rhodes | Mr. Edward Dicey | Mr. Gladstone | Mr. Statham | Lord Randolph Churchill
Outcome:     Motion: carried on | Motion: agreed on | Motion: passed by
Defendant:   at Netley | of the
Publication: The Times
Division:    Ayes 96, Noes 56 | Ayes 127, Noes 23 | Ayes 93, Noes 57
Hansard:     S4V0087P0 | S4V0088P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

MR. ASQUITH said on the point of order raised by the hon. Member for East Northamptonshire he might be permitted to explain the matter as it appeared to him. The Amendment was really consequential upon the alterations made in the Bill by the House of Lords in the schedule. If the Amendment were passed before the schedule were dealt with, it might apply to numbers which the House of Lords and this House did not intend that it should apply to.

MR. SPEAKER : In that case it might be convenient that it should be postponed. 816 The consideration of the Lords Amendment was postponed. The next Amendment, page 5, line 9, agreed to. Lords Amendment, in page 6, line 8 (to leave out "exceeding one acre"), read a second time.

Motion made, and Question proposed, "That this House doth agree with the Lords in the said Amendment."

*MR. CHANNING said that the leaving out of those words would have the result of still compelling the farmer to obtain the consent of his landlord to plant osiers, whatever the area. Compensation would only be paid subject to the consent of the landlord being obtained. The small concessions made by the Bill appeared to him to be whittled away by this Amendment of the Lords, and he hoped the Government would resist it, having regard to the fact that the provision as originally drawn had been supported by a large majority of the House.

Sir ROBERT EINLAY hoped that the House would agree with the Lords Amendment. He was informed by those who had more knowledge of t

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: trespass | railway | election | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-048 | 1907 | Unknown | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Roberts | Lord Justice Romer | Mr. Lowther | Mr. Hargreaves Brown | Sir Thomas Esmonde | Sir Erskine May | Mr. Speaker | Mr. Charles Walker
Outcome:     Motion: passed on | Motion: carried on
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: If their Report | I am bound by the four corners of this Report | Members who look upon this Report | Department I will not look to the Report | On reading the Report
Division:    Ayes 154, Noes 72 | Ayes 72, Noes 153 | Ayes 159, Noes 64
Hansard:     S4V0091P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

*MR. BRODRICK : I hold no brief for the Hospitals Commission, but I know that they are a body of thoroughly high-minded gentlemen who gave an immense amount of time and hard work to this subject, who travelled a great many thousand miles, and who took up this inquiry for a public purpose, and reported on matters as they found them-If their Report is not altogether satisfactory to my hon. friend and to some other hon. Members of this House, I can only say that so far as I am concerned I do not feel that I am bound by the four corners of this Report as to what requires to be done in the Army. In the nature of things it cannot be an exhaustive Report. Looking at this matter quite impartially, I think the hon. Member cast a very unmerited slur upon the Commission when he said that these gentlemen concluded their labours by appointing a Committee to do the very work which they had been appointed to do. That was not an accurate statement of the facts. This Commission was appointed to consider and report 540

MR. BURDETT-COUTTS : I am sorry that the late hour at which I spoke obliged me to leave out some very important parts of my speech. I had intended to close with the sentence that if you had any doubt upon this point, it was only necessary to examine the' evidence which followed Lord Roberts's evidence, and it would be found that not a single officer in the Army afterwards gave an opinion opposite to that expressed by Lord Roberts.

MR. BRODRICK : I confess that I can produce o

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: railway | election | Election | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-049 | 1908 | Unknown | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Sir James Blyth | Mr. Chancellor | Lord Advocate | Lord Lieutenant | Mr. Edward Morphy | Mr. Frederick Boyle | Mr. Boyle | Mr. Attorney
Outcome:     Motion: carried by
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Question on the Paper | The Post | Motion placed on the Paper | Motion now on the Paper | Notice Paper
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S4V0102P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

MR. THOMAS BAYLEY : I beg to ask the President of the Local Government Board whether his attention has been drawn to the use of smallpox virus passed through pustules on monkeys as a source of vaccine by Dr. S. Monckton Copeman, Medical Inspector Local Government Board, who states that a considerable number of children have been vaccinated with vaccine thus obtained; and whether the Local Government Board has given its medical inspector leave to vaccinate children with vaccine of such a nature.

MR. WALTER LONG : Dr. Copeman informs me that he has made experiments of the kind referred to in the Question. The Local Government Board have not given him permission to vaccinate children with lymph yielded by the monkey, and I understand that he has not in fact done so. In all cases the vaccinations have been performed with lymph derived directly from the calf.

SIR WALTER FOSTER (Derbyshire, Ilkeston) : I beg to ask the President of the Local Government Board if he can state the localities in which the farms are situated at which the experiments of the Royal Commission on Tuberculosis will be carried out, and the conditions on which these farms have been obtained and the necessary laboratories and buildings erected.

MR. WALTER LONG : The two farms referred to are situated in Stansted, in Essex. They belong to Sir James Blyth, who has most generously placed them at the disposal of the Royal Commission for experimental work free of charge. The Government have expressed to Sir Jame

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | election | Municipal | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-050 | 1909 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Lieutenant | Mr. Corr | Mr. Chancellor | Mr. Denis Johnston | Mr. Speaker | Mr Cardwell | Mr. Austen Chamberlain | Lord Roberts
Outcome:     Motion: passed by | Motion: carried by | Motion: carried without | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: Bill introduced | Motion: Bill read | Motion: carried on | Motion: Passed by
Defendant:   showed that | won
Publication: The Report | As for the Papers | Member with the Report | We have to get the Report | Notice on the Paper | Press Telegrams between the General Post | General Post | We have adopted the very words of the Report
Division:    Ayes 182, Noes 143 | Ayes 170, Noes 135 | Ayes 262, Noes 19 | Ayes 157, Noes 106 | Ayes 139, Noes 56 | Ayes 41, Noes 129
Hansard:     S4V0104P0 | S4V0105P0 | S4V0107P0 | S5CV0012P0 | S5CV0013P0 | S5LV0007P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Petitions against: From Itchen; Middlesbrough; Winsford; Congleton; Northwich; Tynemouth; Emlyn; Malton; North of England United Coal Trade Association; Wigan; Swansea; Ryton; Blaydon; Mining Association of Great Britain; Chester-le-Street; and Whickham; to lie upon the Table.

Petition from Manchester, in favour; to lie upon the Table.

Return presented relative thereto [ordered 18th March; Mr. Archdale ]; to lie upon the Table.

Copy presented of Agreement for the Exchange of Press Telegrams between the General Post Office of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland, and the General Post Office of Norway [by Command]; to lie upon the Table.

Copy presented of Draft Rule proposed to be made by the Secretary of State for the Home Department under the Prisons Acts, 1877 and 1898, with respect to the constitution of the Visiting Committee of Brixton Prison [by Act]; to lie upon the Table.

[SECOND READING.]

Order for Second Reading read.

*(12.10.) MR. CHAPMAN (Cheshire, Hyde) : In rising to move the Second Reading of the Rating of Machinery Bill I must claim the indulgence of the House, inasmuch as the exigencies of the ballot have placed this Bill in my hands. I feel myself unworthy of the position in the presence of so many hon. Members who have taken up this question in times past, and I feel my inability to do justice to the subject as I am addressing the House for the first time. The practical issue is of great importance, and yet the subject is so complicated an

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | Poor Law | Municipal | poor law | election | friendly society | building society | Election | 7 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Stockdale v Hansard case
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-051 | 1910 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Alfred Hutton | Mr. Samuel Erans | Mr. Disraeli | Lord Carnarvon | Lord Salisbury | Sir Stafford Northcote | Lord Kimberley | Mr. Butt
Outcome:     Motion: Bill passed | Motion: carried on | Motion: passed on | Motion: Bill read | Motion: Bill introduced | Motion: passed by | Motion: passed without | Motion: carried by
Defendant:   of
Publication: Chairman left the Chair to make his Report | Committee on whose Report | Amendment next on the Paper | Daily Chronicle | The mere laying of a single Paper | That the several Papers | Motion that stands in my name on the Paper | Five years after the Report
Division:    Ayes 132, Noes 257 | Ayes 277, Noes 48 | Ayes 221, Noes 52 | Ayes 189, Noes 254 | Ayes 186, Noes 271 | Ayes 190, Noes 282 | Ayes 196, Noes 296 | Ayes 271, Noes 170
Hansard:     S4V0113P0 | S5CV0017P0 | S5CV0019P0 | S5CV0021P0 | S5CV0023P0 | S5CV0024P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

The SECRETARY of STATE for the HOME DEPARTMENT (Mr. Churchill) rose in his place and claimed to move, "That the Question be now put."

Question put, "That the Question be now put."

The Committee divided: Ayes, 181; Noes, 116.

Question put, "That those words be there added."

The Committee divided: Ayes, 121; Noes, 183.

Lord HUGH CECIL : I have handed in an Amendment in manuscript and I submit that it ought to be discussed now, the more so as I understand that my hon. Friend the Member for Sheffield asked whether an Amendment to the Amendment could be moved when the Closure was moved. Therefore, I submit that as part 738 of the rights of the minority, of which the Chair is guardian, I am entitled to move this Amendment at the present stage.

The CHAIRMAN (Mr. Emmott) : I do not think that the Noble Lord's Amendment is in order. I am informed that the Deputy-Chairman ruled that it could not 739 be moved as a separate proposition. The Noble Lord's Amendment seems to me to be entirely covered by the discussion we have just had.

Lord HUGH CECIL : I submit that the speech made by the Prime Minister precisely did not affect my Amendment, though it did affect the Amendment of my hon. Friend. The Prime Minister's speech evidently regulated the whole discussion. It was really the only important speech made against the Amendment, and therefore an Amendment which is not obnoxious to his criticism and which raises a new point ought to be submitted to the judgment of the Committee.

T

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Election | election | tithe | Municipal | Land Tax | Railway | Tithe | municipal | 33 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-052 | 1910 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Wyndham | Lord Hugh Cecil | Mr. Bonar Law | Mr. John Redmond | Lord Grey | Duke of Wellington | Sir Robert Peel | Mr. Balfour
Outcome:     Motion: passed by | Motion: passed on | Motion: carried on | Motion: carried by
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Morning Post | Amendment which stands second on the Paper | Committee and on the Report | The Times | Amendment had been put on the Paper | I would point out that after the Report | Amendments is not to put them on the Paper | Amendment circulated with the Papers
Division:    Ayes 335, Noes 205 | Ayes 348, Noes 209 | Ayes 289, Noes 145 | Ayes 291, Noes 146 | Ayes 311, Noes 216 | Ayes 103, Noes 222
Hansard:     S4V0112P0 | S5CV0022P0 | S5CV0029P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Mr. WEDGWOOD : Could he not have done it on his own?

Mr. BONAR LAW : Why should he be attacked for exercising that right? [An HON. MEMBER: "He is not being attacked."] The Prime Minister said he would have been attacked. There is nothing to my mind which shows more the baseness—that is the word that was in my mind, but perhaps it is too strong a word— 1007 there is nothing more than that which shows the undesirableness of the course pursued by the Prime Minister. He knew and he was right that we who sit on this side of the House would not, under any circumstances, attack the King. [HON. MEMBERS: "Oh, oh."] He preyed upon that knowledge, and deliberately refrained from giving the King the advice which he ought to have given to him because some of the Gentlemen below the Gangway might attack the King.

Mr. RAMSAY MACDONALD : May I ask if the right hon. Gentleman means that we should have done that more than he is doing himself at the present moment?

Mr. BONAR LAW 1008 speeches. I tried to make it an issue over and over again, at least a dozen times in Manchester, and I was met by cries: "That is not the issue; that is a bogey." We did try to make it the issue, but we failed, and it is because we failed that right hon. Gentlemen and hon. Gentlemen opposite are now sitting on that Bench. The Home Secretary last night, in an amusing impromptu which, for greater accuracy, he had committed to writing, referred to the courage of my right hon. Friends the Member for Dover (Mr. Wynd

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: election | Election | railway | 4 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-053 | 1911 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Duke of Devonshire | Lord Advocate | Lord Blafour | Mr. Rochefort Maguire | Mr. Hooley | Mr. Mac | Sir Alexander Acland | Mr. Hayes Fisher
Outcome:     Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill read | Motion: passed by | Motion: Bill introduced | Motion: passed without | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: carried by | Motion: Passed by
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Minister at Peking forwarding a Report | The Times | SPEAKER laid upon the Table Report | General Report | First Report | Parliamentary Paper | The Report | That was the basis of the Report
Division:    Ayes 190, Noes 139 | Ayes 214, Noes 113 | Ayes 206, Noes 100 | Ayes 68, Noes 180
Hansard:     S4V0118P0 | S4V0119P0 | S5CV0032P0 | S5CV0033P0 | S5CV0042P0 | S5CV0044P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

MR. SWIFT MACNEILL said he thought the Secretary of State for War was able to defend himself, even though he could not defend his office.

MR. STRUTT said the right hon. Gentleman had not asked him to defend him.

MR. SWIFT MACNEILL said there was one observation he felt bound to make, which he thought would anticipate an argument which the First Lord of the Treasury might advance in his reply. 388 No doubt the right hon. Gentleman would reply very well, because he knew nothing about the subject. It might be said that Gentlemen on the Treasury Bench, many of whom were not wealthy men, should be allowed to eke out the pittance given to them by an ungrateful and parsimonious country by accepting directorships. At present eighteen Ministers, the greatest geniuses the earth had ever produced, were where starving themselves on salaries amounting to &93,000 per annum, and they held fourteen directorships. He stated, and he would defy contradiction, that thirty-three out of fifty-six Ministers of the Crown who constituted the present Administration held sixty-eight directorships. In that was included the Chancellor of the Exchequer, who had now been converted, and, therefore, the correct number of Ministers holding directorships was thirty-two, and they held no fewer then sixty-eight directorships. Out of the 670 members of the House only thirty-two per cent. were directors, but more than fifty per cent. of the members of the Government, who ought to give all their time to the coun

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | Duchy | railway | election | municipal | friendly society | Election | Poor Law | 42 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-054 | 1912 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Mc | Sir Lewis Dibdin | Mr. Pollock | Mr. Hoare | Sir Charles Nicholson | Mr. Ellis Davies | Mr. Maclean | Mr. Hobhouse
Outcome:     Motion: passed by | Motion: carried on
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: The latest is the Report | As stated in the Final Report | Schedule was to look at the Report | Gentleman will turn to the Report | White Paper | Labour Gazette | I hope that the particulars given in the Report | Special Report
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S4V0123P0 | S4V0126P0 | S5CV0047P0 | S5CV0048P0 | S5CV0050P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Lord C. BERESFORD : Before I criticise the speech of the First Lord of the Admiralty, I should like to reply to the hon. Gentleman opposite (Mr. Keir Hardie). I think that what he has said is liable to be the cause of a great deal of mischief in Canada. I hold no brief for the First Lord of the Admiralty, but I do like to see fair play. What happened was that the Canadian Government wrote to the First Lord inquiring whether he would give the opinion of the Admiralty and the experts as to how they should carry out their naval policy. The First Lord sent the opinion of the experts, and not his own, and I do think that the hon. Member is very hard upon the right hon. Gentleman, and that what he has said may make a great deal of mischief. During a long career, off and on, in this House I have often attended Naval debates, but I have never heard a cleverer speech than that which was delivered by the First Lord of the Admiralty last night.

Mr. KEIR HARDIE : I am sure the Noble Lord does not wish to misrepresent me. If he will turn to the copy of the correspondence between the First Lord of the Admiralty and the Prime Minister of 1913 the Dominion of Canada he will find in the communication, dated 24th January, 1913, addressed to "My dear Mr. Borden" and signed, "Yours very sincerely, Winston S. Churchill," the statement on which I based my statement. If the officer who was asked to provide the statement went out of his way to take a part as between the two parties in Canada, the 

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Municipal | tithe | DUCHY | Railway | election | railway | 3 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-055 | 1912 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Cromer | Mr. Chancellor | Mr. Emmott | Lord Lieutenant | Lord Clanricarde | Lord Advocate | Mr. Hanbury | Lord Roberts
Outcome:     Stay of proceedings | Motion: carried on
Defendant:   of the
Publication: Designs for the new Post | Irish Land Bill is down for Report | Honours Gazette | Bath in the Gazette | The Times
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S4V0125P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

*MR. BRODRICK : My attention has been called to the case in question, and to the observations of the magistrate. The Adjutant-General informs me this morning that Lieutenant Prior has tendered his resignation, but that he will be informed that if he does not take measures to prove his innocence of the grave imputations made against him, it will be necessary to consider his removal from the Army.

MR. SWIFT MACNEILL : I beg to ask the Secretary of State for War whether he is aware of the trial by mock Court-martial on, and the treatment by twelve officers of, a subaltern in the transport "Staffordshire," on the voyage to the Cape on New Year's Eve; and, if so, will he state what action he proposes to take in the matter.

*MR. BRODRICK : Nothing is known at the War Office of this matter.

MR. FULLER (Wiltshire, Westbury) : I beg to ask the Secretary of State for War whether it is proposed to use the Porthcawl Rifle Range for field firing; and, if so, whether he can state the artillery units that are likely to use it.

THE FINANCIAL SECRETARY TO THE WAR OFFICE (Lord STANLEY, Lancashire, Westhoughton ) : This range will be used for field firing, but not by Royal Artillery.

MR. SOARES (Devonshire, Barnstaple) : I beg to ask the Secretary of State for War whether he is aware that there is this year a reduction in the number of recruits for the Volunteer forces in North Devon, and that there is dissatisfaction amongst the Volunteers with the rate of 862 the pay allowed to them whi

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: election | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-056 | 1912 | s.3 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Sir Arthur Hardinge | Mr. Chancellor | Lord Advocate | Mr. Justice Darling | Mr. Pinchard | Mr. Arthur Elliot | Mr. Victor Cavendish | Sir Joseph Lawrence
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: I have to say that Papers | With regard to the additional Paper | Notice Paper | The Report | Question than I put on the Paper
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S4V0126P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

LORD CRANBORNE : I must ask for notice of that.

MR. LOUGH : May I ask the First Lord of the Treasury if he does not think that the discussion on this Bill should be postponed until we have the Report of the proceedings and the particulars of the countervailing duties.

THE PRIME MINISTER AND FIRST LORD OF THE TREASURY (Mr. A. J. BALFOUR, Manchester, E.) : No, Sir.

LORD EDMUND TALBOT (Sussex, Chichester) : I beg to ask the Under Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether the correspondence between His Majesty's Government and the French Government, relating to the English Benedictines at Douai, will be laid upon the Table.

LORD CRANBORNE : In reply to the noble Lord's first Question, I have to say that Papers will be laid. With regard to the additional Paper which the noble Lord speaks of, I will do my utmost to satisfy him; but I cannot answer quite off-hand.

MR. AUSTIN TAYLOR (Liverpool, East Toxteth) : Will the noble Lord also include any correspondence relating to the general legislation of the French Government in respect to these Orders, which was the subject of his criticisms last week.

LORD CRANBORNE : I do not think that really arises on the Question. I must ask the hon. Member for notice.

SIR H. CAMPBELL-BANNERMAN (Stirling Burghs) : I beg to ask the Under Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs what was the date of the signature of the Commercial Convention between the United Kingdom and Persia, Government in regard to the modification or interpretation of

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: railway | 1 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-057 | 1913 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Wyndham | Mr. Gladstone | Mr. Mc | Sir Horace Plunkett | Mr. Mr | Lord Iveagh | Mr. Pirrie | Mr. Trevelyan
Outcome:     Motion: passed on | Motion: carried by | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill introduced | Motion: Bill read | Motion: passed by | Motion: Motion agreed
Defendant:   in the | suing in | in an
Publication: Member for Cork had also referred to the Report | Allport Commission made a similar Report | Irish railways and The Times | Colonies whether he has yet received a Report | The number of Post | The Report | I find myself obliged to criticise this Report | Member referred to the Report
Division:    Ayes 87, Noes 121
Hansard:     S4V0130P0 | S5CV0061P0 | S5CV0066P0 | S5LV0040P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_168

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Read a second time, and committed.

* MR. J. F. X. O'BRIEN (Cork) said he wished to call the attention of the House to the question of transit and railway rates in Ireland; and to move, "That, in the opinion of this House, excessive railway rates and defective transit facilities generally constitute a serious bar to the material advancement of Ireland, and should receive immediate attention from the Government." It was a mere truism to say that the railway system of Ireland could, and ought to, help powerfully towards facilitating and developing the prosperity and trade of that country. But he regretted to say that at no time had that railway system been a help. On the contrary it had always been a great hindrance to trade in Ireland. So oppressive, indeed, had it been, that it had made the development of trade in that country impossible. The following figures showed very briefly how railway travelling was discouraged in Ireland, as compared with England and Scotland. In 1880 the average Irish railway rates were higher by 21·83 per cent. than the English, and 27·13 per cent. above the Scotch; in 1890 they were 22·75 per cent. above the English, 29·22 per cent. above the Scotch; in 1900 they were 37·14 per cent. above the English, and 33·97 per cent. above the Scotch. On 15th April, 1902, Mr. Wyndham, who was then Chief Secretary, acknowledged the correctness of these figures. Now, a striking result of these excessive 808 rates charged by the Irish railways was, that while in

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: railway | Railway | Municipal | Poor Law | tithe | RAILWAY | election | Election | 4 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-058 | 1913 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Mc | Mr. Montagu | Mr. Wedgwood Benn | Mr. Birrell | Mr. Harold Baker | Mr. Tennant | Mr. Gulland | Sir John French
Outcome:     Motion: carried on
Defendant:   first to | may give | goes on | outlines in | but the | has been
Publication: Member will look at the Order Paper | Daily Chronicle | New York Times | The New York Times | Copy presented of Report | Annual Report
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S5CV0066P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Lord ROBERT CECIL asked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether his attention has been called to the publication by the German Government of certain proposals which are alleged to have been made to secure French and English neutrality during the War; and whether the publication is complete and accurate?

The SECRETARY of STATE for FOREIGN AFFAIRS (Sir E. Grey) : I have seen an incomplete publication. The circumstances were as follows—

It was reported to me one day that the German Ambassador had suggested that Germany might remain neutral in a war between Russia and Austria, and also engage not to attack France, if we would remain neutral and secure the neutrality of France. I said at once that, if the German Government thought such an arrangement possible, I was sure we could secure it.

It appeared, however, that what the Ambassador meant was that we should 390 secure the neutrality of France if Germany went to war with Russia. This was quite a different proposal, and, as I supposed it in all probability to be incompatible with the terms of the Franco-Russian Alliance, it was not in my power to promise to secure it.

Subsequently, the Ambassador sent for my private secretary, and told him that, as soon as the misunderstanding was cleared up, he had sent a second telegram to Berlin to cancel the impression produced by the first telegram he had sent on the subject.

The first telegram has been published. This second telegram does not seem to have been published.



FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Friendly Society | 2 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-059 | 1913 | s.3 | NEEDS_REVIEW
================================================================
Status:      NEEDS_REVIEW
MP/Lord:     Not extracted
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Not extracted
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S4V0131P0
Journals:    nan

COMBINED CONTEXT: [No wide-context passage available — see existing knowledge report]

FORENSIC NOTES:
None
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-060 | 1914 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Mac | Mr. Darbyshire | Mr. Mc | Mr. Asquith | Mr. Dillon | Mr. Whitley | Earl of Ancaster | Viscount Peel
Outcome:     Motion: Resolved in | Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: carried on | Motion: Motion  withdrawn | Motion: Bill  read
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Pelham Committee and the Post | I have an Amendment on the Paper | Amendments on the Paper | Amendment on the Paper | Bill a provision such as I have on the Paper | Viscount to this very excellent Report | On  Report
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S5CV0088P0 | S5LV0043P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_169

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

THE EARL OF PORTSMOUTH

THE EARL OF ANCASTER : As your Lordships think that there should be a time limit, I ask leave to withdraw my original Motion and will move in its place the Amendment which I have already foreshadowed.

Original Motion, by leave, withdrawn.

Moved, That this House doth not insist upon the said words, but proposes in lieu thereof and a person shall not be entitled to recover under the subsection wages for more than three months or for such longer period not exceeding one year as the court in which proceedings are taken for the recovery of the wages shall consider just."—( The Earl of Ancaster. )

THE MARQUESS OF SALISBURY : I think the proposal of the Government—rather irregularly made, may I say, as the noble Earl has made another Motion—is very cumbersome and difficult to estimate on the spur of the moment. I do not 893 think your Lordships ought to be asked to assent to it in this fashion. There is a very simple question as to whether the word"six"is the right. one. Upon that I think there is the possibility of compromise. Any reasonable man would say that and I suggest that six is the best word. But I see there is a difference of opinion in your Lordships' House on that. point, and if the Government wished to move to leave out"six"and put it some some other figure I think we could consider it. I am afraid that we cannot accept the amendment which the noble Earl has moved, and if it is put from the Woolsack I shall vote against it as it stands.

Reso

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | DUCHY | 3 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-061 | 1915 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Earl of Crawford | Lord Newton | Lord Meath | Sir Frederick Banbury | Sir William Plender | Lord Gorell | Lord Crawford | Lord Long
Outcome:     Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill read | Motion: Bill
read
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: I put this Motion on the Paper | Lordships will remember that the Bryce Report | Bryce Report | That was not the policy of the Bryce Report | The Bryce Report | Proceedings on Report
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S5LV0051P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_170

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Returned from the Commons, with the Amendments, agreed to.

Returned from the Commons, with the Amendments, agreed to.

Returned from the Commons, with the Amendments, agreed to.

Returned from the Commons, agreed to, with Amendments: The said Amendments considered, and agreed to.

The House met at a quarter past four of the clock, the LORD CHANCELLOR on the Woolsack.

Read 3 a , with the Amendment, and passed, and returned to the Commons.

Read 3 a , with the Amendments, and passed, and returned to the Commons.

Read 3 a (according to Order), with the Amendments, and passed, and returned to the Commons.

Read 3 a (according to Order), with the Amendment, and passed, and returned to the Commons.

Brought from the Commons; read 1 a , and to be printed.

Brought from the Commons; read 1 a , and to be printed.

Brought from the Commons; read 1 a , and to be printed.

Brought from the Commons; read 1 a , and to be printed.

THE FIRST COMMISSIONER OF WORKS (THE EARL OF CRAWFORD) : My Lords, I beg to make the Motion of which I have given Notice—namely, That Standing Orders Nos. XXI and XXXIX be 951 considered in order to their being dispensed with until the adjournment for the recess. I put this Motion on the Paper in order to expedite business in so far as that is compatible with the proper examination of the measures submitted to the House. Standing Order No. XXI relates to priority of Notices and Standing Order No. XXXIX prevents more than one stage of Bills being taken on a si

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: municipal | railway | election | ELECTION | Duchy | 10 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-062 | 1916 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Mc | Lord Derby War | Mr. Rendall | Lord Barrymore | Mr. Bonar Law | Mr. Hayes Fisher | Mr. Booth | Mr. Prothero
Outcome:     Motion: carried on | Motion: passed by | Motion: passed on | Motion: passed without | Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: Bill read | Motion: Bill

Introduced
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: March last by one of the Post | It has given its Report | May I ask which of the Orders on the Paper | Anyone who has studied the Report | House I put an Amendment on the Paper | White Paper | Every effort will be made to prevent Post | Dwyer has been in the employment of the Post
Division:    Ayes 17, Noes 61
Hansard:     S5CV0107P0 | S5CV0110P0 | S5CV0118P0 | S5LV0060P0 | S5LV0062P0 | S5LV0063P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_171

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Mr. R. McNEILL asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland, in view of the fact that 518 the farming interest in Great Britain has been so gravely disturbed by compulsory recruitment for the Army that essential agricultural work is only carried on with extreme effort and difficulty, and with the assistance of female and prisoner labour, if he will say why there is no intention of disturbing the farming interest in Ireland, where agricultural labour is abundant in proportion to the needs of the land; and if the expectation that not many of the rural population will prove available for military purposes signifies that Ireland is not to be called upon for sacrifice comparable with that required of Great Britain?

Mr. SHORTT : Having regard to the great increase in tillage and the importance to the United Kingdom of food production in Ireland, agricultural labour in Ireland is not abundant in proportion to the needs of the land. Ireland is being called upon to make sacrifices comparable with the rest of the Empire.

Mr. McNEILL asked the Chief Secretary for Ireland if he will say, having regard to the fact that Ireland, with a population approximately the same as that of Scotland, has contributed by voluntary enlistment 400,000 fewer recruits to the Army than Scotland, why 50,000 new recruits is regarded as an equitable ratio for Ireland; and, in view of the Prime Minister's statement two months ago that the need for recruits from Ireland was then urgent and immediate, why it has been

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: election | Railway | Municipal | Election | Tithe | municipal | tithe | railway | 12 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-063 | 1917 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Chancellor | Mr. Victor Cavendish | Mr. Flynn | Mr. Soares | Mr. Shackleton | Lord Barrymore | Lord Clonbrock | Lord Randolph Churchill
Outcome:     Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: passed on | Motion: Bill

Introduced | Motion: motion withdrawn | Motion: passed by | Motion: Resolved in | Motion: Motion agreed
Defendant:   and to | in
Publication: Annual Report | Parliamentary Paper | Members the Report | I have not received the Report | I have received the Report | General Post | White Paper | Royal Commission Report
Division:    Ayes 225, Noes 125 | Ayes 221, Noes 123 | Ayes 204, Noes 102
Hansard:     S4V0151P0 | S5CV0125P0 | S5LV0065P0 | S5LV0067P0 | S5LV0068P0 | S5LV0069P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

First Resolution.

£ s. d. Total Surpluses 1,143,259 15 4 Total Deficits 901,653 9 4 Net Surplus £241,606 6 0

And whereas the Lords Commissioners of His Majesty's Treasury have temporarily authorised the application, in reduction of the net charge on Exchequer Grants for certain Army Services, of the whole of the sums received in excess of the estimated Appropriation-in-Aid, in respect of the same Services, and have also temporarily authorised the application of so much of the said total surpluses on certain Grants for Army Services as is necessary to cover the said total deficits on other Grants for Army Services.

1. "That the application of such sums be sanctioned."

Question put, "That this House doth agree with the Committee in the said Resolution."

The House divided:—Ayes, 225; Noes, 125. (Division List No. 334.)

Second Resolution.

Question put, "That this House doth agree with the Committee in the said Resolution."

The House divided:—Ayes, 221; Noes, 123. (Division List No. 335.)

Resolutions reported.

1. "That, towards making good the Supply granted to His Majesty for the service of the year ended on the 31st day of March, 1904, the sum of £1,445 17s. 4d. be granted out of the Consolidated Fund of the United Kingdom."

2. "That, towards making good the Supply granted to His Majesty for the service of the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1906, the sum of £66,495,748 be granted out of the Consolidated Fund of the United Kingdom."

Resolutions agreed to.

Bil

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: election | Railway | railway | Election | Municipal | Tithe | Land Tax | DUCHY | 21 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-064 | 1918 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Olivier | Earl of Birkenhead | Earl of Onslow | Lord Onslow | Lord Parmoor | Lord Ponsonby | Lord Banbury | Lord Chairman
Outcome:     Motion: Bill passed | Motion: passed without | Motion: Bill read | Motion: carried on | Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: motion agreed
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: We have put an Amendment on the Paper | Lord has an Amendment on the Paper | Amendment I have put on the Paper | Order of the Day for receiving the Report | Order of the Day discharged and Report | Order Paper | The Times | Many of us know that Report
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S5LV0074P0 | S5LV0078P0 | S5LV0080P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

American attitude re , and suspicion, (72), 51–3, 56.

British commitments, and question of present position re , (72), 55–7, 60.

Italian attitude re , and suspicion, (72), 51–3, 56.

Motion, (72), 47–61, 74, 94.

Set-back to cause of disarmament, (72), 47–8, 52–3, 60–1.

Trained reservists question, (72), 53–5.

Local Government Bill, 2R, (72), 1118–24, 1150.

Overseas Trade Bill, 2R, (72), 102–8.

War Debts:

Balfour Memorandum, Debate on Motion, (74), 365–6, 367, 368–9, 369–70, 373, 374, 375–6.

Settlements, Labour party attitude, (74), 373–6.

Tobacco industry,

de-rating, estimated relief from, (72), 797–8.

Tomlin, Baron, of Ash,

introduced, (72), 911.

Tonbridge Electricity (Extension) Order, 1929:

Referred to Special Orders Committee, (72), 1096; Report from Special Orders Committee, (73), 688; Approved, 691.

Torquay Extramural Cemetery Company Bill,

Standing Orders complied with, (72), 786; 1R * , (73), 455; Standing Orders complied with, 684–5; 2R * , 689; Reported, 973; 3R * , (74), 12; Royal Assent, 226.

Treowen, Lord,

Reconstituted Cream Bill, Committee, (74), 423.

Trinidad Legislative Council:

Motion (Lord Olivier), not proceeded with, (72), 684.

Nominee membership, revocation of disqualification of persons holding contracts with Government, (73), 758–61.

Tunbridge Wells Corporation Bill [H.L.],

Standing Orders complied with, (72) 786; Intro. * and 1R * , 799; 2R * , 833; Committed, 976; Select Committee, appointment, 1161; appointment of Members, (

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Municipal | railway | election | municipal | Election | 3 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-065 | 1919 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Mr. Wheatley | Sir John Tudor | Duke of Westminster | Lord Bishop | Lord Jessel | Lord Balfour | Lord Buckmaster | Mr. Neville Chamberlain
Outcome:     Motion: Motion passed | Motion: Bill read | Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: carried on | Motion: passed by
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: The Times | London County Council appeared in The Times | Motion for Papers | Amendment Paper | We can only hope when the Report | First Report | I beg to move that this Report | The substance of it is contained in this Report
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S5LV0081P0 | S5LV0083P0 | S5LV0084P0 | S5LV0085P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

LORD PONSONBY OF SHULBREDE : As the noble Marquess is aware, we have no objection at all to the suspension of the Standing Order.

House adjourned at twenty minutes past six o'clock.

The House met at eleven of the clock, The EARL OF LUCAN on the Woolsack.

Read 2 a .

LORD TEMPLEMORE : My Lords, on behalf of my noble friend the Chairman of Committees, I beg to move that Standing Order No. 171 be considered in order to its being dispensed with in respect of this Bill.

Moved, That Standing Order No. 171 be considered in order to its being dispensed with in respect of the said Bill, and that the Bill be now read 3 a .—( Lord Templemore. )

On Question, Motion agreed to: Bill read 3a accordingly, and passed, and sent to the Commons.

Brought from the Commons, endorsed with the certificate from the Speaker that the Bill is a Money Bill within the meaning of the Parliament Act, 1911; and read 1 a .

Brought from the Commons; read 1 a ; to be printed, and referred to the Examiners.

THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR AIR (THE MARQUESS OF LONDONDERRY) : My Lords, on behalf of my noble friend the Leader of the House, I beg to move that Standing Order No. XXXIX be considered in order to its being suspended for this day's sitting.

Moved, That Standing Order No. XXXIX be considered in order to its 1044 being suspended for this day's sitting.—( The Marquess of Londonderry. )

LORD PONSONBY OF SHULBREDE : My Lords, I should like to draw the attention of the noble Marquess to the wording of the

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: municipal | Land Tax | land tax | Election | Railway | Land tax | 15 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-066 | 1920 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Earl of Kinnoull | Viscount Cecil | Duke of Montrose | Earl of Denbigh | Earl of Listowel | Lord Chamberlain | Lord Snell | Lord Redesclale
Outcome:     Motion: passed by | Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: carried on | Motion: Bill introduced | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: Bill read | Motion: passed on | Motion: carried by
Defendant:   in the
Publication: I should like to see it go through Report | Motion standing on the Order Paper | LORD STIIACHIE had an Amendment on the Paper | I have ventured to put on the Paper | Motion which is on the Order Paper | First Report | Motion for Papers | If we can get through the Order Paper
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S5LV0089P0 | S5LV0092P0 | S5LV0093P0 | S5LV0094P0 | S5LV0095P0
Journals:    HCJ_volume_175

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

National Government, achievements of, Debate on the Address, [86] 8–12.

National finance, necessity of economy, Debate on the Address, [86] 11.

Performing Animals (Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2R, [87] 736–9, 744.

Chester Gas Order, 1933:

Referred to Special Orders Committee, [88] 710; Report from Special Orders Committee, [88] 1167; Approved, [88] 1178.

Children,

birching of, abolition, Motion (Earl of Kinnoull), [88] 1083–94.

Children and Young Persons Bill [H.L.]:

Motion for leave to introduce, and 1R, [86] 1082; 1R * , [86] 1082; 211, [86] 122(5–7; Referred to Joint Committee on Consolidation Bills, [86] 1227; Report from Joint Committee on Consolidation Bills, [87] 38; Reported and re-committed to Committee of the Whole House, [87] 93; Committee * , [87] 138; 3R * , [87] 182; Returned from the Commons agreed to with an Amendment, [87] 548; Commons Amendment considered and agreed to, [87] 548; Royal Assent., [87] 596.

King's Speech on Prorogation of Parliament, [89] 4.53–4.

China:

Government policy in, Motion (Earl Peel), [89] 54–79.

and Japan, Motions (Viscount Cecil), [86] 100–43; [87] 872–901.

Church of Scotland (Property and Endowments) Amendment Bill [H.L.],

Motion for leave to introduce and 1R, [86] 971; 1R * , [86] 973; 2R, [86] 1089–90; Committee, [87] 766–76, Report * , [87] 854; 311, [87] 974; Returned from Commons, agreed to, with Amendments, [88] 920; Commons Amendments considered and agreed to, [88] 1115–6; Royal Assent, [88] 1214.

Churchill, V

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | Election | election | Tithe | municipal | Poor Law | trespass | railway | 19 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced; Dual Hansard + Journal confirmation
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-067 | 1921 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Viscount Gage | Lord Gage | Viscount Bertie | Lord Bertie | Lord Somers | Lord Gainford | Earl of Munster | Lord Snell
Outcome:     Motion: Bill read | Motion: Bill passed | Motion: carried on | Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: passed by | Motion: passed without
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Amendments on the Paper | ELIBANK had the following Notice on the Paper | Motion I have put on the Paper | I will put the question on the Notice Paper | Motion and no Question on the Order Paper | Lord Peel has a Motion on the Paper | Statutory Papers
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S5LV0101P0 | S5LV0104P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Clause 263, page 166, line 11, leave out ("the preceding subsection") and insert ("this section").—( Viscount Gage. )

On Question, Amendments agreed to.

Clause 269:

Power of local authority to control use of moveable dwellings.

(5) Nothing in this section applies—

(ii) to a moveable dwelling (belonging to a person who is the proprietor of a travelling circus, roundabout, amusement fair or store (not being a pedlar, hawker, or costermonger) while it is being used by him in the course of travelling for the purpose of his business; or

(6) If an organisation satisfies the Minister that it takes reasonable steps for securing— ( a ) that camping sites belonging to or provided by it, or used by its members, are properly managed and kept in good sanitary condition; and ( b ) that moveable dwellings used toy its members are so used as not to give rise to any nuisance, the Minister may grant to that organisation a certificate of exemption.

In this subsection the expression "member" in relation to an organisation includes a member of any branch or unit of the organisation.

VISCOUNT BERTIE OF THAME moved, in paragraph (ii) of subsection (5), after "fair," to insert "stall." The noble Viscount said: My Lords, I suggest to my noble friend Lord Gage that the word "stall" should be inserted in this clause because it is a well-known term in the show world. "Stallholder" includes those responsible for all the smaller games and that sort of thing other than roundabouts, circuses, and s

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Election | Railway | tithe | Tithe | 5 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-068 | 1922 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Earl of Radnor | Earl of Feversham | Earl of Munster | Lord President | Lord Privy Seal | Lord Strabolgi | Lord Salisbury | Lord Chatham
Outcome:     Motion: Bill read | Motion: Motion agreed
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Day for the consideration of the Third Report | I beg to move that this Report | Judges Report | Statutory Papers | Special Report | Royal Commission Report | Motion for Report
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S5LV0105P0 | S5LV0106P0 | S5LV0110P0 | S5LV0112P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

3. Before confirming any livestock markets byelaws submitted to him for confirmation, the appropriate Minister shall consider any objections to the byelaws which have been duly made, and may, after holding such inquiries (if any) as he thinks fit, make such modifications in the bylaws as he may, after consultation with the Commission, consider desirable:

Provided that—…

THE EARL OF RADNOR moved to leave out "bylaws" and insert "bye-laws": The noble Earl said: In the course of my researches, in connection with this Bill, into Reports in another 612 place and in this House, I have discovered four different spellings of the word "by-laws." Two of them appear within a few lines of each other here. All the different ways are correct, but I wish they would stick to one! I beg to move.

Amendment moved— Page 54, line 30, leave out ("bylaws") and insert ("byelaws").—( The Earl of Radnor. )

VISCOUNT BERTIE OF THAME : I regret to inform your Lordships that, according to Fowler, who has very often been quoted against me, neither the noble Earl nor the Government is correct. The proper form, according to Fowler, is "by-law."

THE EARL OF RADNOR : May I say that is as it is printed in the OFFICIAL REPORT of your Lordships' House.

THE EARL OF FEVERSHAM : I will certainly look into it, and perhaps I shall have an opportunity of making a lengthy statement on this Amendment at the next stage!

Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.

Fourth Schedule agreed to.

Fifth Schedule agreed to.

Sixth S

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Duchy | Railway | railway | 10 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-069 | 1923 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Viscount Trenchard | Lord Straholgi | Lord Davies | Lord Templemore | Lord Snell | Lord Chamberlain | Lord Addison | Lord Bishop
Outcome:     Unknown
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Fifth Report | White Paper | Third Report
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S5LV0114P0 | S5LV0117P0 | S5LV0118P0 | S5LV0119P0 | S5LV0120P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Civil Service,

appointment, promotion and dismissal, rules governing, [117] 140–1.

Clacton Urban District,

Sunday Entertainments Act Order, Laid before the House, [117] 40; Approved, [117] 73.

Clanwilliam, Earl of,

Home Guard, organisation, Debate on Motion, [117] 708–10, 716.

Clarendon, Rt. Hon. the Earl of, Lord Chamberlain:

Government of India (Adaptation of Acts of Parliament) (Amendment) Order, Message from the King, [116] 380.

India and Burma Orders, Message from the King, [115] 733.

King's Speech, Address in reply, Message from the King, [115] 201.

Louise, Her Royal Highness the Princess, death, Address, Message from the King, [115] 201.

Clearing Office Amendment Orders, see under Rumania, Spain and Turkey.

Cleethorpes Borough,

Sunday Entertainments Act Order, Laid before the House, [115] 769; Approved, [115] 771.

Clifden, Viscount,

Physical training, Debate on Motion, [116] 1032–6.

Clwyd, Lord,

Norman Maltzahn, case of, question, [117] 351–3, 354.

Clyde Lighthouses Consolidation Order Confirmation Bill,

1R * , [117] 419; deemed to have been 2R and reported, [117] 419; Reports * , [117] 572; 3R * , [117] 572; Royal Assent, [117] 608.

Coal,

Commission, Valuation and Supplies, Motion (Lord Addison), [116] 242–64.

Coast Protection Act, 1939,

Newhaven (Sussex) Prohibitory Order, see that title .

Coast Towns, Losses in,

Question (Lord Bishop of Norwich), [117] 491–500.

Cobham, Viscount, Under-Secretary of State for War:

Army and Air Force (Annual

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: election | Election | Railway | 23 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-070 | 1923 | s.2 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Croft | Earl of Cork | Lord Mottistone | Lord Marchwood | Mr. Cross | Lord Snell | Mr. Herbert Morrison | Lord Addison
Outcome:     Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: Bill read
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Motion for Papers | TRABOLGI had the following Notice on the Paper | Motion on the Paper | I beg to move for Papers | Has this question on the Paper | The Report | Lordships to the Report | White Paper
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S5LV0119P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

Prisoners of war, British, Debate on questions re, 107–9.

Propaganda, Debate on Motion, 519, 812–8.

Road accidents and Departmental instructions, Question, 75.

War, recent events in Mediterranean area, Debate on Motion, 467–73.

Welles, Mr. Sumner, speech by, Question, 1088.

Cecil of Essendon, Lord (Viscount Cranborne), Secretary of State for the Dominions :

Anglo-Portuguese trade, Debate on Motion, 186–8, 192.

Prisoners of war, British:

in Germany, reports received from American Embassy in Berlin, 109–10.

Treatment of, and administration of question, 109–15.

Propaganda, Debate on Motion, 551–62.

Russia, war with Germany, statement, 485–7.

Temporary Migration of Children (Guardianship) Bill, Motion for leave to introduce and 1R, 30; 2R, 159–64, 166–8; Committee, 200–2.

Central (Coal Mines) Scheme (Amendment) Order,

Referred to Special Orders Committee, 229; Report from Special Orders Committee, 206; Approved, 340.

Central Electricity Board (Increase of Borrowing Powers) Special Order, 1941,

Referred to Special Orders Committee 377; Report from Special Orders Committee, 563; Approved, 643.

Chairman,

Pharmacy and Medicines Bill, Committee, 1025.

Channel Islanders,

in H.M. Forces, family allowances to, Motion (Lord Bishop of Winchester), 674–80.

Channel Islands,

communications with, 902–6.

Chartered and Other Bodies (Temporary Provisions) Bill,

Returned from the Commons, agreed to, 80; Royal Assent, 116.

Cherwell of Oxford, Baron,

introduced, 695.

Civi

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: Railway | Election | 9 high-conf hits in wide-context pass
================================================================

================================================================
CASE PPA-071 | 1924 | s.1 | CONFIRMED
================================================================
Status:      CONFIRMED
MP/Lord:     Lord Samuel | Lord Trenchard | Viscount Trenchard | Sir Earle Page | Viscount Cranborne | Mr. Menzies | Lord Croft | Lord Lloyd
Outcome:     Motion: passed by | Motion: carried on | Motion: Motion agreed | Motion: Bill read
Defendant:   Not extracted
Publication: Motion for Papers | The first is from the Report | I would venture to make is from a Report | This is the Report | Commission state in the course of their Report
Division:    No division recorded
Hansard:     S5LV0121P0
Journals:    None

COMBINED CONTEXT (best passage from Hansard + Journals):

LORD STRABOLGI : I am very much obliged to the noble Lord, but may I point out that "uniform" is an elastic-term, and if a conspicuous badge would serve the purpose, why not?

LORD CROFT : My Lords, the noble and gallant Viscount opposite courteously 90 indicated that his question had mostly to do with women's service in the A.T.S., and my noble friend, therefore, asked me to reply. May I say that I was very interested to hear the speech of the noble Viscount, Lord Samuel, who dealt with the wider question of labour conditions in factories and canteens and other walks of labour, and I am sure that the Minister of Labour and the Minister of Health will be very interested to read his remarks. I will most certainly call their attention to the valuable contribution the noble Viscount made to this debate. With regard to the remarks of the noble Lord who has just sat down, it is quite new to me that there has been any question of a uniform for munition workers. I am sure that the suggestion the noble Lord has made will be read with interest, but I am afraid that is a subject upon which I am not very competent to enter at the present time. The noble Viscount, whose great services in building up the Royal Flying Corps and the foundations of the Royal Air Force are in everyone's minds to-day, nevertheless has always, in spite of his great activities with the air arm, continued to take the keenest interest in the Army, to which he gave so many years of his early service. I appreciate,

FORENSIC NOTES:
FP-flags: election | municipal | railway | 2 high-conf hits in wide-context pass | Speaker's certificate referenced
================================================================
